For Sale7d on marketHistoric · 126 yrs
1409 E New York St
Indianapolis, IN, 46201 • Near Eastside • Marion County
$400,000
$147/sqft
Down payment assistance available
3Beds
2Baths
2,724Sqft
0.13 acLot
1900Built
Property DNA
Traditional Style
Built 1900 · 126 years of history
Arsenal Park
Near Eastside
Outdoor Living
Deck · Glass Enclosed
2-Car Garage
Detached
Premium Finishes
Hardwood Floors · Walk-In Closet(s)
Hardwood Floors
Quality flooring throughout
This home is in high demand
Listed 7 days ago · 1,400 views · 111 saves · Top 7% likely to sell soon
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
1,400 views
People checking out this listing
111 saves
Buyers have saved this home
7 days on market
Just listed — act fast
$147/sqft
Price per square foot
Selling Soon Prediction
Very HighThis home ranks in the top 7% of listings most likely to go under contract soon, based on market activity and demand signals.
Likelihood score
Want the full market analysis?
Get the detailed selling prediction score, comparable sales data, and price trend forecast for this property.
Free · Delivered to your inbox in minutes
About this home
Single Family · Built 1900 · Historic
Located in the heart of Holy Cross, this 3-bedroom, 2 full bath home with a rare 2-car garage combines historic character with thoughtful updates in one of downtown Indianapolis' most desirable neighborhoods. Original features stand out throughout, including 10' ceilings, beautiful pocket doors, exposed brick, a cozy sunroom, and striking entryway pillars that create a warm first impression. Natural light fills the home and highlights the hardwood floors and comfortable living areas. The spacious dining room is perfect for hosting, and the large exterior deck extends your entertaining outdoors. The primary bedroom offers great natural light and a generous walk-in closet. Nearly all mechanicals have been updated within the last six years, providing added peace of mind. An unfinished basement offers flexible use and plenty of storage. Enjoy easy access to Mass Ave, Bottleworks District, the Monon Trail, Highland Park, King Dough, 3 Dolls Bakery, Natural State Provisions, Futuro Pizzeria, and more, making it easy to enjoy the best of downtown living.
Standout features identified
Our analysis highlights cozy sunroom, striking entryway pillars, and exposed brick as key attractions of this home.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$2,505/month
Principal & Interest$1,972
Property Tax$400
Insurance$133
Down payment20% ($80,000)
3%50%
Est. 6.26% rate · 30yr fixed · $320,000 loan
Full calculator →Video Tour
Open in new tab ↗Loading video tour…
At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeResidential, Single Family Residence
Year Built1900
HeatingForced Air, Natural Gas
CoolingCentral Air
Parking2 Garage spaces
Lot5,662 sqft
Days on Zillow7 Days
Price/sqft$147
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Sub-typeResidential, Single Family Residence
StyleTraditional
Year built1900
Stories2
Systems
HeatingForced Air, Natural Gas
CoolingCentral Air
ConstructionBrick, Vinyl Siding
Water / SewerPublic
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingDetached
Garage2 spaces
BasementUnfinished
FencingFenced,Full
Lot5,662 sqft
Location & Tax
NeighborhoodNear Eastside
Annual tax$3,750
Parcel491006161013000101
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths2
Features & details
11 categories of property features
Interior Features
Interior
Attic Access
High Ceilings
Entrance Foyer
Ceiling Fan(s)
Hardwood Floors
High Speed Internet
Wired for Data
Pantry
Smart Thermostat
Walk-In Closet(s)
Appliances
Dishwasher
Dryer
Electric Water Heater
Disposal
Microwave
Electric Oven
Refrigerator
Washer
Water Softener Owned
Flooring
Hardwood
Heating
Forced Air
Natural Gas
Cooling
Central Air
Laundry
Main Level
Exterior Features
Parking
Detached
Construction
Brick
Vinyl Siding
Patio & Porch
Deck
Glass Enclosed
Lot Features
Sidewalks
Street Lights
Mature Trees
Trees-Small (Under 20 Ft)
Security
Carbon Monoxide Detector(s)
Room details
10 rooms detailed
Master Bedroom
Upper15×14 ft210 sqft
Bedroom2
Upper13×11 ft143 sqft
Bedroom3
Upper12×11 ft132 sqft
Dining Room
Main15×13 ft195 sqft
Foyer
Main15×11 ft165 sqft
Kitchen
Main13×12 ft156 sqft
Tile-Ceramic
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusFor Sale
Days on market7
Tax rate0.96%
Price/sqft$147
On marketApr 1, 2026
PostedApr 1, 2026
Last sold$346,000
MLS statusActive
MLS updatedApr 3, 2026
Tour days9
Views1,400
Favorites111
How are the schools in Indianapolis?
3 schools rated nearby
Location
Indianapolis, IN, 46201
Price history
12 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Apr 1, 2026Listed For Sale$400,000$147MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Apr 8, 2021Sold$346,000$127MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Aug 29, 2016Sold$213,000$78MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Jul 10, 2016Pending Sale$210,000$77Nottingham Realty Group
Jul 2, 2016Listed For Sale$210,000$77Nottingham Realty Group
Jun 18, 2014Sold$152,900$56MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Jun 3, 2014Pending Sale$154,900$57F.C. Tucker Company, Inc.
May 30, 2014Listed For Sale$154,900$57F.C. Tucker Company, Inc.
Jul 1, 2009Sold$132,000$48Public Record
Apr 2, 2009Price Change$125,000$46CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Feb 18, 2009Price Change$129,900$48CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Dec 6, 2008Listed For Sale$139,900$51CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Listed For Sale$400,000
Apr 1, 2026•$147/sqft•MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Sold$346,000
Apr 8, 2021•$127/sqft•MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Sold$213,000
Aug 29, 2016•$78/sqft•MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Pending Sale$210,000
Jul 10, 2016•$77/sqft•Nottingham Realty Group
Listed For Sale$210,000
Jul 2, 2016•$77/sqft•Nottingham Realty Group
Sold$152,900
Jun 18, 2014•$56/sqft•MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Pending Sale$154,900
Jun 3, 2014•$57/sqft•F.C. Tucker Company, Inc.
Listed For Sale$154,900
May 30, 2014•$57/sqft•F.C. Tucker Company, Inc.
Sold$132,000
Jul 1, 2009•$48/sqft•Public Record
Price Change$125,000
Apr 2, 2009•$46/sqft•CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Price Change$129,900
Feb 18, 2009•$48/sqft•CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Listed For Sale$139,900
Dec 6, 2008•$51/sqft•CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Tax history
20 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 8, 2024$3,747$313,100
Apr 8, 2023$3,862$313,300
Apr 8, 2022$3,214$320,500
Apr 8, 2021$2,868$274,400
Apr 8, 2020$2,775$244,800
Apr 8, 2019$2,547$232,800
Apr 8, 2018$2,183$212,500
Apr 8, 2017$2,147$201,600
Apr 8, 2016$2,156$198,400
Apr 8, 2014$1,377$128,400
Apr 8, 2013$1,613$122,100
Apr 8, 2012$1,613$120,800
Apr 8, 2011—$98,400
Apr 8, 2010$1,074$98,400
Apr 8, 2009$684$88,200
Apr 8, 2007—$116,900
Apr 8, 2004—$55,100
Apr 8, 2003—$55,100
Apr 8, 2002—$19,300
Apr 8, 2001—$6,600
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Indianapolis, IN • Marion County
Nearby neighborhoods
Chapel Hill-Ben DavisDowntownEagledaleEast WarrenFar EastsideGarden CityNear EastsideSnacks-Guion CreekSouth FranklinSouth Perry
Nearby cities
Beech GroveCumberlandIndianapolisLawrenceSouthportSpeedway
Nearby zip codes
46203462174621946220462224622446226462274623746254
Similar homes
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2026-04-08 09:12:55 PDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. [Click here for more information](/mls-disclaimers/#48)
No obligation · Same-day response