Off Market9294d on marketHistoric · 95 yrs
5301 Graceland Ave
Indianapolis, IN, 46208 • Butler-Tarkington • Marion County
$449,700
$255/sqft
3Beds
2Baths
1,765Sqft
1931Built
Property DNA
Character Home
Built 1931 · 95 years of history
Hardwood Floors
Quality flooring throughout
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
1 views
People checking out this listing
9294 days on market
Established listing
$255/sqft
Price per square foot
About this home
Single Family · Built 1931 · Historic
For rent is a beautiful 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath house in the highly desirable Butler Tarkington area. Just a 2-minute walk from Butler University, Shops at 56th and IL, and Canal Path trail. Located on a quiet street lined with mature trees, this is the perfect house for anyone looking for a home, not a rental. The house features a recently updated kitchen, a large deck for entertaining, a 2-car detached garage, a partially finished basement, and hardwood floors. A fenced-in yard makes this house pet-friendly. Date Available: August 1, 2025. $2,500/month rent. A $2,500 security deposit is required. A one-year lease is preferred. Monthly rent $2,500 and security deposit $2,500.
Standout features identified
Our analysis highlights partially finished basement, fenced-in yard, and quiet street as key attractions of this home.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$2,933/month
Principal & Interest$2,333
Property Tax$450
Insurance$150
Down payment20% ($89,940)
3%50%
Est. 6.75% rate · 30yr fixed · $359,760 loan
Full calculator →At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeSingle Family Residence
Year Built1931
HeatingFireplace
CoolingAir Conditioner, Central Air, Ceiling Fan
ParkingAttached Garage
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Sub-typeSingle Family Residence
Year built1931
Systems
HeatingFireplace
CoolingAir Conditioner, Central Air, Ceiling Fan
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingAttached, Off Street
FencingFenced Yard
Location & Tax
NeighborhoodButler-Tarkington
Annual tax$7,628
Parcel490611104211000801
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths1
Features & details
8 categories of property features
Interior Features
Interior
Ceiling Fan(s)
Storage
Appliances
Dishwasher
Disposal
Dryer
Microwave
Range Oven
Refrigerator
Trash Compactor
Washer
Flooring
Hardwood
Heating
Fireplace
Cooling
Air Conditioner
Central Air
Ceiling Fan
Laundry
In Unit
Exterior Features
Exterior
Balcony
Granite countertop
Lawn
Living room
Stainless steel appliances
Parking
Attached
Off Street
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusOff Market
Days on market9294
Est. value$449,700
Est. rent$2,408/mo
Tax rate0.96%
Price/sqft$255
On marketMay 15, 2025
PostedMay 15, 2025
Last sold$205,000
MLS updatedMay 15, 2025
Tour days6
Views1
How are the schools in Indianapolis?
3 schools rated nearby
Location
Indianapolis, IN, 46208
Price history
18 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Jun 5, 2025Listing Removed$2,500$1Zillow Rentals
May 15, 2025Listed For Rent$2,500$1Zillow Rentals
Mar 9, 2023Listing Removed——Zillow Rentals
Dec 24, 2022Listed For Rent$2,500$1Zillow Rentals
Dec 2, 2022Listing Removed——Zillow Rental Manager
Oct 25, 2022Listed For Rent$2,500$1Zillow Rental Manager
Jun 28, 2021Listing Removed——Zillow Rental Manager
Jun 2, 2021Listed For Rent$2,500$1Zillow Rental Manager
Feb 23, 2021Listing Removed——Owner
Jun 9, 2020Listing Removed$2,250$1Owner
Apr 20, 2020Price Change$2,250$1Owner
Feb 26, 2020Price Change$2,300$1Owner
Feb 10, 2020Listed For Rent$2,500$1Owner
Feb 22, 2019Listing Removed$2,250$1Owner
Jan 6, 2019Listed For Rent$2,250$1Owner
Jun 5, 2018Listing Removed$2,250$1Owner
May 7, 2018Listed For Rent$2,250$1Owner
Nov 2, 2000Sold$205,000$116MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Listing Removed$2,500
Jun 5, 2025•$1/sqft•Zillow Rentals
Listed For Rent$2,500
May 15, 2025•$1/sqft•Zillow Rentals
Listing Removed—
Mar 9, 2023•Zillow Rentals
Listed For Rent$2,500
Dec 24, 2022•$1/sqft•Zillow Rentals
Listing Removed—
Dec 2, 2022•Zillow Rental Manager
Listed For Rent$2,500
Oct 25, 2022•$1/sqft•Zillow Rental Manager
Listing Removed—
Jun 28, 2021•Zillow Rental Manager
Listed For Rent$2,500
Jun 2, 2021•$1/sqft•Zillow Rental Manager
Listing Removed—
Feb 23, 2021•Owner
Listing Removed$2,250
Jun 9, 2020•$1/sqft•Owner
Price Change$2,250
Apr 20, 2020•$1/sqft•Owner
Price Change$2,300
Feb 26, 2020•$1/sqft•Owner
Listed For Rent$2,500
Feb 10, 2020•$1/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed$2,250
Feb 22, 2019•$1/sqft•Owner
Listed For Rent$2,250
Jan 6, 2019•$1/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed$2,250
Jun 5, 2018•$1/sqft•Owner
Listed For Rent$2,250
May 7, 2018•$1/sqft•Owner
Sold$205,000
Nov 2, 2000•$116/sqft•MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID
Tax history
23 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 15, 2024$7,628$340,700
Apr 15, 2023$6,829$321,600
Apr 15, 2022$6,236$289,700
Apr 15, 2021$6,729$270,700
Apr 15, 2020$6,791$291,000
Apr 15, 2019$4,537$288,100
Apr 15, 2018$3,989$368,800
Apr 15, 2017$3,857$365,400
Apr 15, 2016$2,385$356,700
Apr 15, 2014$3,609$327,600
Apr 15, 2013$2,868$286,900
Apr 15, 2012$2,868$251,200
Apr 15, 2011—$221,300
Apr 15, 2010$2,343$221,300
Apr 15, 2009$2,648$244,900
Apr 15, 2007—$230,900
Apr 15, 2006—$240,300
Apr 15, 2005—$178,700
Apr 15, 2004—$178,700
Apr 15, 2003—$178,700
Apr 15, 2002—$59,700
Apr 15, 2001—$19,900
Apr 15, 2000—$19,900
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Indianapolis, IN • Marion County
Nearby neighborhoods
Chapel Hill-Ben DavisDowntownEagledaleEast WarrenFar EastsideGarden CityNear EastsideSnacks-Guion CreekSouth FranklinSouth Perry
Nearby cities
Beech GroveCumberlandIndianapolisLawrenceSouthportSpeedway
Nearby zip codes
46203462174621946220462224622446226462274623746254
Similar homes
No obligation · Same-day response