For Sale9d on market
5892 Whitney Bay Rd
Mayville, NY, 14757 • 14757 • Chautauqua County
$629,000
$624/sqft
Down payment assistance available
3Beds
1Baths
1,008Sqft
0.33 acLot
1953Built
Property DNA
On the Chautauqua Lake
Beach Access, Dock Access, Lake
Water Views
Water
Cottage Style
Built 1953 · 73 years of history
Premium Finishes
Granite Counters
Hardwood Floors
Quality flooring throughout
This home is getting attention
Listed 9 days ago · 1,260 views · 43 saves
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
1,260 views
People checking out this listing
43 saves
Buyers have saved this home
9 days on market
Recently listed
$624/sqft
Price per square foot
About this home
Single Family · Built 1953
Turnkey lakefront cottage with 80 feet on frontage! This 4 season lake home currently operates as a short term rental(currently sleeps 9), with an exceptional longstanding rental history. Tucked away in a private and peaceful setting, this 3 bedroom home is a true hidden gem. Inside you will find updated finishes, a newly remodeled bathroom, and a loft-style upstairs bedroom that adds charm and extra sleeping space. The kitchen features granite countertops, and beautiful wood floors that run throughout the home. Enjoy looking at the lake in either the screened in sunroom, or off of the back deck. A heated shed with electricity and an additional half bathroom adds additional storage, or the opportunity to be converted into a bunk-house. Home is being sold fully furnished, minus a couple items. Major improvements include: converted into 4 season cottage, close cell foam insulation, converted from propane to natural gas, new water heater, added washer & dryer capabilities, new well, loft fully remodeled, new flooring throughout entire home, new water pump, updated kitchen and fully remodeled bathroom, replaced outdoor decks, replaced windows, and custom blinds for screened porch. Whether you are looking for a move in ready vacation home or a turnkey rental, look no further!
Standout features identified
Our analysis highlights replaced outdoor decks, private and peaceful setting, and replaced windows as key attractions of this home.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$3,957/month
Principal & Interest$3,119
Property Tax$629
Insurance$210
Down payment20% ($125,800)
3%50%
Est. 6.31% rate · 30yr fixed · $503,200 loan
Full calculator →At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeSingle Family Residence
Year Built1953
HeatingGas
CoolingWindow Unit(s)
ParkingNo Garage
Lot0.33 Acres
Days on Zillow9 Days
Price/sqft$624
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Sub-typeSingle Family Residence
StyleCottage
ConditionResale
Year built1953
Systems
HeatingGas
CoolingWindow Unit(s)
ConstructionSpray Foam Insulation, Vinyl Siding
Water / SewerWell / Connected
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingNo Garage
BasementCrawl Space
Lot0.33 Acres
Location & Tax
Neighborhood14757
Annual tax$7,240
Parcel06288931412115
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths1
Features & details
11 categories of property features
Interior Features
Interior
Granite Counters
Bedroom on Main Level
Loft
Appliances
Dryer
Gas Oven
Gas Range
Gas Water Heater
Refrigerator
Washer
Flooring
Hardwood
Luxury Vinyl
Other
See Remarks
Varies
Heating
Gas
Cooling
Window Unit(s)
Exterior Features
Exterior
Dirt Driveway
Parking
No Garage
Construction
Spray Foam Insulation
Vinyl Siding
Lot Features
Irregular Lot
Secluded
Views
Water
Utilities
Sewer Connected
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusFor Sale
Days on market9
Est. value$634,800
Est. rent$1,233/mo
Tax rate2.10%
Price/sqft$624
On marketMar 30, 2026
PostedMar 30, 2026
Last sold$220,000
MLS statusActive
MLS updatedApr 6, 2026
Tour days9
Views1,260
Favorites43
How are the schools in Mayville?
2 schools rated nearby
Location
Mayville, NY, 14757
Price history
3 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Mar 30, 2026Listed For Sale$629,000$624NYSAMLSs
Dec 23, 2015Sold$220,000$218Public Record
Aug 18, 2015Listed For Sale$239,000$237Howard Hanna Holt
Listed For Sale$629,000
Mar 30, 2026•$624/sqft•NYSAMLSs
Sold$220,000
Dec 23, 2015•$218/sqft•Public Record
Listed For Sale$239,000
Aug 18, 2015•$237/sqft•Howard Hanna Holt
Tax history
19 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 9, 2025—$260,000
Apr 9, 2024—$260,000
Apr 9, 2023—$260,000
Apr 9, 2022—$260,000
Apr 9, 2021—$260,000
Apr 9, 2020—$217,000
Apr 9, 2019—$217,000
Apr 9, 2018—$217,000
Apr 9, 2016—$217,000
Apr 9, 2015—$217,000
Apr 9, 2014—$205,000
Apr 9, 2013—$205,000
Apr 9, 2012—$205,000
Apr 9, 2011—$205,000
Apr 9, 2010—$172,500
Apr 9, 2009—$172,500
Apr 9, 2008—$172,500
Apr 9, 2007—$172,500
Apr 9, 2006—$150,500
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Mayville, NY • Chautauqua County
Nearby cities
AshvilleDunkirkFalconerForestvilleFredoniaFrewsburgJamestownLakewood
Nearby zip codes
14757
Similar homes
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, UNYREIS and WNYREIS. Real estate listings held by firms other than Zillow, Inc. are marked with the IDX logo and include the Listing Broker’s Firm Name. Listing Data last updated at 2026-04-08 17:18:56 PDT. Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither the listing broker(s) nor Zillow, Inc. shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. © 2026 CNYIS, UNYREIS, WNYREIS. All rights reserved.
No obligation · Same-day response