Off Market1777d on marketHistoric · 156 yrs

258 Montgomery St

Newburgh, NY, 12550 • 12550 • Orange County

$613,200

$228/sqft

4Beds

3Baths

2,685Sqft

0.06 acLot

1870Built

Property DNA

1 highlights

Character Home

Built 1870 · 156 years of history

Market activity

Demand and pricing signals for this listing

1 views

People checking out this listing

1777 days on market

Established listing

$228/sqft

Price per square foot

About this home

Multi Family · Built 1870 · Historic

This 2685 square foot multi family home has 4 bedrooms and 3.0 bathrooms. This home is located at 258 Montgomery St, Newburgh, NY 12550.

Estimated monthly payment

Based on current rates

$3,787/month

Principal & Interest$2,969

Property Tax$613

Insurance$204

Down payment20% ($122,640)

3%50%

Est. 6.09% rate · 30yr fixed · $490,560 loan

Full calculator →

At a glance

Key facts and listing details

TypeMultiFamily

Year Built1870

HeatingOther

ParkingNo Data

Property

Home typeMulti Family

Year built1870

Systems

HeatingOther

Constructionbrick

Parking & Outdoor

BasementFinished

Lot2,614 sqft

Location & Tax

Neighborhood12550

Parcel3311001031

Features & details

3 categories of property features

Interior Features

Heating

Other

Exterior Features

Exterior

Brick

Construction

brick

Listing insights

Market data and value estimates

StatusOff Market

Days on market1777

Est. value$613,200

Est. rent$2,788/mo

Tax rate1.94%

Price/sqft$228

Last sold$105,500

Tour days6

How are the schools in Newburgh?

3 schools rated nearby

Horizon On The Hudson Magnet School

Primary • Public • PK-5

0.3 mi

South Middle School

Middle • Public • 6-8

1.4 mi

Newburgh Free Academy Main Campus

High • Public • 9-12

1.1 mi

Location

Newburgh, NY, 12550

Expand map

Price history

3 events

DateEventPrice$/sqftSource

Jun 2, 2021Sold$105,500$39Public Record

Feb 27, 2007Sold$420,000$156Public Record

Jun 19, 2003Sold$189,900$71Public Record

Sold$105,500

Jun 2, 2021•$39/sqft•Public Record

Sold$420,000

Feb 27, 2007•$156/sqft•Public Record

Sold$189,900

Jun 19, 2003•$71/sqft•Public Record

Tax history

8 years of records

YearTax paidAssessed value

Apr 15, 2025—$586,300

Apr 15, 2024—$542,900

Apr 15, 2023—$517,000

Apr 15, 2022—$502,700

Apr 15, 2021—$418,900

Apr 15, 2020—$380,800

Apr 15, 2019—$241,700

Apr 15, 2018—$195,200

Nearby homes

Off Market

2 bd1 ba800 sqft

258 Montgomery St FLOOR 2, Newburgh, NY

Off Market

$555,200

4 bd3 ba2,268 sqft

256 Montgomery St, Newburgh, NY

Off Market

2 bd1 ba1,700 sqft

256 Montgomery St FLOOR 1, Newburgh, NY

Off Market

1 bd1 ba890 sqft

256 Montgomery St APT 3, Newburgh, NY

Off Market

$195,200

4 bd3 ba1,885 sqft

258 Montgomery St, Newburgh, NY

Off Market

$195,200

6 bd3 ba1,885 sqft

258 Montgomery St, Newburgh, NY

Off Market

2 bd1 ba900 sqft

254 Montgomery St APT 3, Newburgh, NY

Recently Sold

$675,000

2,742 sqft

254 Montgomery St, Newburgh, NY

Neighborhood details

Local context around this listing

Newburgh, NY • Orange County

Nearby cities

ChesterGoshenMiddletownMonroeMontgomeryNew WindsorNewburghPort Jervis

Nearby zip codes

12550125511255212555

Similar homes

For Sale

$599,000

5 bd3 ba2,340 sqft

290 1st Street, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$649,000

4 bd3 ba2,430 sqft

175 Liberty Street, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$599,000

4 bd3 ba2,324 sqft

6 Rutland Lane, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$625,000

3 bd3 ba1,866 sqft

4 Broad Street, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$567,000

5 bd4 ba2,816 sqft

171 Chambers Street, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$649,000

7 bd4 ba2,955 sqft

154 3rd Street, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$619,000

4 bd3 ba2,540 sqft

10 Glen Lane, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$585,000

3 bd3 ba2,483 sqft

108 Williamsburg Court, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$669,000

5 bd4 ba3,312 sqft

166 Brookside Farms, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$799,999

4 bd3 ba3,128 sqft

2 Pond Ridge Crossing, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$550,000

4 bd2 ba1,760 sqft

86 William Street, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$599,990

6 bd3 ba3,120 sqft

168 Fostertown Road, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$629,000

4 bd3 ba2,217 sqft

LOT 8 Lindenwood Lane, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$525,000

4 bd2 ba2,092 sqft

15 Waring Road, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$679,900

4 bd3 ba2,832 sqft

41 Hickory Hill Road, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$399,000

3 bd2 ba1,716 sqft

22 E Parmenter Street, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$575,000

5 bd3 ba2,431 sqft

17 Shaker Court, New Windsor, NY

For Sale

$569,900

3 bd3 ba2,768 sqft

123 Foxwood Drive S, Newburgh, NY

350 N Water Street Bldg 6- Unit 6, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$399,999

3 bd3 ba1,528 sqft

350 N Water Street Bldg 6- Unit 6, Newburgh, NY

For Sale

$650,000

4 bd2 ba2,000 sqft

122 Route 17K, Newburgh, NY

Tour This Home

Pick a date

Preferred time

Apr 15, 2026

No obligation · Same-day confirmation · Takes 30 seconds

Need a different time? Request custom scheduling

Have a Question?

Get details on this property, the neighborhood, or the buying process.

Ask About This Property

We typically respond within a few hours

Download property brochure

Photos, details & neighborhood info in one PDF

Get brochure

Free · No sign-up required

Get pre-approved

Know your budget & strengthen your offer

Check eligibility

Value estimates

Live

Est. value$613,200

Est. rent$2,788/mo

30yr rate est.6.09%

Affordability$4,209/mo

Own a home nearby?

See what it's worth in today's market

Get estimate

Schedule Tour Ask

No obligation · Same-day response