For Sale40d on marketHistoric · 130 yrs
5869 Broadway St
Lancaster, NY, 14086 • 14086 • Erie County
$359,900
$156/sqft
+$10,000 since Mar 29, 2026
Down payment assistance available
6Beds
3Baths
2,303Sqft
0.87 acLot
1896Built
Property DNA
Detached,Duplex Style
Built 1896 · 130 years of history
Holland Land Company's Su
14086
2-Car Garage
Garage · Paved
Tile Floors
Quality flooring throughout
This home is in high demand
Listed 40 days ago · 4,873 views · 249 saves · Top 5% likely to sell soon
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
4,873 views
People checking out this listing
249 saves
Buyers have saved this home
40 days on market
Established listing
$156/sqft
Price per square foot
Selling Soon Prediction
Very HighThis home ranks in the top 5% of listings most likely to go under contract soon, based on market activity and demand signals.
Likelihood score
Want the full market analysis?
Get the detailed selling prediction score, comparable sales data, and price trend forecast for this property.
Free · Delivered to your inbox in minutes
About this home
Multi Family · Built 1896 · Historic
Completely renovated 2-unit multi-family property in Lancaster offers strong income potential and modern upgrades throughout. Each unit features 3 bedrooms, a living room, a formal dining room, a full kitchen, and 1 full bathroom. The lower unit also includes an additional half bathroom for added convenience. Recent updates include new kitchens, new bathrooms, new flooring throughout, fresh interior paint, updated lighting fixtures, and a new HVAC system. Move-in ready condition with extensive improvements already completed. Spacious layouts in both units make this property ideal for owner-occupants or investors. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, and major roadways. Turnkey opportunity in a desirable suburban location. The square footage differs from the tax records, see the floor plan in the attachments. Open House March 7th & 8th (Saturday & Sunday) Between 1:00 PM – 3:00 PM
Standout features identified
Our analysis highlights new bathrooms, new hvac system, and new kitchens as key attractions of this home.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$2,233/month
Principal & Interest$1,753
Property Tax$360
Insurance$120
Down payment20% ($71,980)
3%50%
Est. 6.14% rate · 30yr fixed · $287,920 loan
Full calculator →Virtual Tour
Open in new tab ↗Loading virtual tour…
At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeDuplex, Multi Family, Single Family Residence
Year Built1896
HeatingGas, Forced Air
Parking2 Garage spaces
Days on Zillow40 Days
Price/sqft$156
Property
Home typeMulti Family
Sub-typeDuplex, Multi Family, Single Family Residence
StyleDetached,Duplex
ConditionResale
Year built1896
Stories2
Systems
HeatingGas, Forced Air
RoofAsphalt
ConstructionAluminum Siding, PEX Plumbing
Water / SewerConnected, Public / Connected
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingGarage, Paved
Garage2 spaces
BasementFull
Lot0.87 Acres
Location & Tax
Neighborhood14086
Annual tax$5,388
Parcel14528911600234
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths2
Features & details
8 categories of property features
Interior Features
Appliances
Gas Water Heater
Flooring
Tile
Varies
Vinyl
Heating
Gas
Forced Air
Accessibility
Accessible Doors
Exterior Features
Parking
Garage
Paved
Construction
Aluminum Siding
PEX Plumbing
Lot Features
Near Public Transit
Rectangular
Rectangular Lot
Residential Lot
Utilities
Sewer Connected
Water Connected
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusFor Sale
Days on market40
Est. value$352,200
Est. rent$1,512/mo
Tax rate1.83%
Price/sqft$156
On marketFeb 27, 2026
PostedFeb 27, 2026
Last sold$125,000
MLS statusActive
MLS updatedApr 4, 2026
Tour days9
Views4,873
Favorites249
How are the schools in Lancaster?
3 schools rated nearby
Location
Lancaster, NY, 14086
Price history
3 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Mar 29, 2026Price Change$359,900$156NYSAMLSs
Feb 27, 2026Listed For Sale$349,900$152NYSAMLSs
May 28, 2025Sold$125,000$54Public Record
Price Change$359,900
Mar 29, 2026•$156/sqft•NYSAMLSs
Listed For Sale$349,900
Feb 27, 2026•$152/sqft•NYSAMLSs
Sold$125,000
May 28, 2025•$54/sqft•Public Record
Tax history
25 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 9, 2024—$163,000
Apr 9, 2023—$163,000
Apr 9, 2022—$163,000
Apr 9, 2021—$163,000
Apr 9, 2020—$163,000
Apr 9, 2019—$125,000
Apr 9, 2018—$125,000
Apr 9, 2017$4,498$125,000
Apr 9, 2016$2,377$125,000
Apr 9, 2015—$125,000
Apr 9, 2014—$125,000
Apr 9, 2013—$125,000
Apr 9, 2012—$125,000
Apr 9, 2011—$125,000
Apr 9, 2010—$125,000
Apr 9, 2009—$125,000
Apr 9, 2008—$125,000
Apr 9, 2007—$125,000
Apr 9, 2006—$125,000
Apr 9, 2005—$125,000
Apr 9, 2004—$78,500
Apr 9, 2003—$78,500
Apr 9, 2002—$78,500
Apr 9, 2001—$78,500
Apr 9, 2000—$78,500
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Lancaster, NY • Erie County
Nearby cities
BuffaloDepewEast AmherstEast AuroraGrand IslandHamburgLancasterOrchard Park
Nearby zip codes
14086
Similar homes
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, UNYREIS and WNYREIS. Real estate listings held by firms other than Zillow, Inc. are marked with the IDX logo and include the Listing Broker’s Firm Name. Listing Data last updated at 2026-04-09 01:20:35 PDT. Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither the listing broker(s) nor Zillow, Inc. shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. © 2026 CNYIS, UNYREIS, WNYREIS. All rights reserved.
No obligation · Same-day response