For Sale1297d on marketHistoric · 128 yrs

31 Cayadutta St

Johnstown, NY, 12095 • 12095 • Fulton County

$165,000

$72/sqft

-$5,000 since Mar 12, 2026

Down payment assistance available

5Beds

2Baths

2,304Sqft

0.15 acLot

1898Built

Property DNA

2 highlights

City Views

City

Character Home

Built 1898 · 128 years of history

This home is getting attention

Listed 1297 days ago · 453 views · 14 saves

Market activity

Demand and pricing signals for this listing

453 views

People checking out this listing

14 saves

Buyers have saved this home

1297 days on market

Established listing

$72/sqft

Price per square foot

Selling Soon Prediction

Moderate

This home ranks in the top 37% of listings most likely to go under contract soon, based on market activity and demand signals.

Likelihood score

Want the full market analysis?

Get the detailed selling prediction score, comparable sales data, and price trend forecast for this property.

Unlock Full Report

Free · Delivered to your inbox in minutes

About this home

Multi Family · Built 1898 · Historic

Attention Investors! This is a two-family home. Two car garage with storage above garage. Off street parking. Fully rented. Price is negotiable, depending.

Standout features identified

Our analysis highlights fully screened-in back deck, storage space, and closets in each room as key attractions of this home.

Estimated monthly payment

Based on current rates

$1,076/month

Principal & Interest$856

Property Tax$165

Insurance$55

Down payment20% ($33,000)

3%50%

Est. 6.75% rate · 30yr fixed · $132,000 loan

Full calculator →

At a glance

Key facts and listing details

TypeMultiFamily

Year Built1898

HeatingBaseboard, Electric, Gas

CoolingNone

Parking4 Parking spaces

Days on Zillow1297 Days

Price/sqft$72

Property

Home typeMulti Family

Year built1898

Systems

HeatingBaseboard, Electric, Gas

CoolingNone

RoofShake / Shingle

ConstructionMetal

Parking & Outdoor

ParkingGarage - Detached, Off-street

BasementPartially finished

Lot6,534 sqft

Location & Tax

Neighborhood12095

Parcel170800162191111

Bathrooms & Fees

Full baths2

Features & details

8 categories of property features

Interior Features

Appliances

Dishwasher

Microwave

Range / Oven

Refrigerator

Flooring

Carpet

Laminate

Heating

Baseboard

Electric

Gas

Cooling

None

Exterior Features

Exterior

Vinyl

Parking

Garage - Detached

Off-street

Construction

Metal

Views

City

Room details

6 rooms detailed

Walk In Closet

Breakfast Nook

Family Room

Laundry Room

Pantry

Workshop

Listing insights

Market data and value estimates

StatusFor Sale

Days on market1297

Est. rent$1,477/mo

Tax rate2.13%

Price/sqft$72

On marketSep 6, 2022

PostedSep 6, 2022

Last sold$91,000

Tour days6

Favorites14

How are the schools in Johnstown?

3 schools rated nearby

Warren Street School

Elementary • Public • 3-6

0.1 mi

Johnstown Senior High School

Middle • Public • 6-12

0.2 mi

N/A

Pleasant Avenue School

Primary • Public • PK-4

0.9 mi

Location

Johnstown, NY, 12095

Expand map

Price history

20 events

DateEventPrice$/sqftSource

Mar 12, 2026Price Change$165,000$72Owner

Jan 4, 2026Listed For Sale$170,000$74Owner

Dec 23, 2025Listing Removed——Owner

Sep 24, 2025Listed For Sale$170,000$74Owner

Sep 11, 2025Listing Removed——Owner

Mar 10, 2025Listed For Sale$170,000$74Owner

Feb 27, 2025Listing Removed——Owner

Nov 29, 2024Listed For Sale$170,000$74Owner

Nov 17, 2024Listing Removed——Owner

Aug 19, 2024Listed For Sale$170,000$74Owner

Jul 20, 2024Listing Removed——Owner

Apr 21, 2024Price Change$160,000$69Owner

Jan 16, 2024Listed For Sale$167,000$72Owner

Jan 4, 2024Listing Removed——Owner

Oct 5, 2023Price Change$165,000$72Owner

Apr 2, 2023Price Change$160,000$69Owner

Mar 22, 2023Price Change$165,000$72Owner

Sep 18, 2022Price Change$170,000$74Owner

Sep 6, 2022Listed For Sale$180,000$78Owner

May 7, 2007Sold$91,000$39Public Record

Price Change$165,000

Mar 12, 2026•$72/sqft•Owner

Listed For Sale$170,000

Jan 4, 2026•$74/sqft•Owner

Listing Removed—

Dec 23, 2025•Owner

Listed For Sale$170,000

Sep 24, 2025•$74/sqft•Owner

Listing Removed—

Sep 11, 2025•Owner

Listed For Sale$170,000

Mar 10, 2025•$74/sqft•Owner

Listing Removed—

Feb 27, 2025•Owner

Listed For Sale$170,000

Nov 29, 2024•$74/sqft•Owner

Listing Removed—

Nov 17, 2024•Owner

Listed For Sale$170,000

Aug 19, 2024•$74/sqft•Owner

Listing Removed—

Jul 20, 2024•Owner

Price Change$160,000

Apr 21, 2024•$69/sqft•Owner

Listed For Sale$167,000

Jan 16, 2024•$72/sqft•Owner

Listing Removed—

Jan 4, 2024•Owner

Price Change$165,000

Oct 5, 2023•$72/sqft•Owner

Price Change$160,000

Apr 2, 2023•$69/sqft•Owner

Price Change$165,000

Mar 22, 2023•$72/sqft•Owner

Price Change$170,000

Sep 18, 2022•$74/sqft•Owner

Listed For Sale$180,000

Sep 6, 2022•$78/sqft•Owner

Sold$91,000

May 7, 2007•$39/sqft•Public Record

Tax history

25 years of records

YearTax paidAssessed value

Mar 27, 2024—$63,000

Mar 27, 2023—$63,000

Mar 27, 2022—$63,000

Mar 27, 2021—$63,000

Mar 27, 2020—$63,000

Mar 27, 2019—$63,000

Mar 27, 2018—$63,000

Mar 27, 2017$1,720$63,000

Mar 27, 2016—$63,000

Mar 27, 2015—$63,000

Mar 27, 2014—$39,800

Mar 27, 2013—$39,800

Mar 27, 2012—$39,800

Mar 27, 2011—$39,800

Mar 27, 2010—$39,800

Mar 27, 2009—$39,800

Mar 27, 2008—$39,800

Mar 27, 2007—$39,800

Mar 27, 2006—$39,800

Mar 27, 2005—$39,800

Mar 27, 2004—$39,800

Mar 27, 2003—$39,800

Mar 27, 2002—$39,800

Mar 27, 2001—$39,800

Mar 27, 2000—$39,800

Nearby homes

Off Market

$84,058

4 bd2 ba3,124 sqft

33 Cayadutta St, Johnstown, NY

Off Market

$130,900

6 bd2 ba2,518 sqft

29 Cayadutta St, Johnstown, NY

Off Market

$118,800

4 bd2 ba2,128 sqft

4 Burton St, Johnstown, NY

Off Market

$8,116

Burton St, Johnstown, NY

Off Market

$66,667

6 bd2 ba2,268 sqft

6 Burton St, Johnstown, NY

Recently Sold

$160,000

6 bd3 ba2,986 sqft

30 Cayadutta St #28, Johnstown, NY

Off Market

$80,400

1 bd1 ba1,684 sqft

8 Burton St, Johnstown, NY

Recently Sold

$55,000

4 bd2 ba2,716 sqft

39 Cayadutta St, Johnstown, NY

Neighborhood details

Local context around this listing

Johnstown, NY • Fulton County

Nearby cities

AmsterdamBroadalbinCaroga LakeDolgevilleFort JohnsonGloversvilleHagamanJohnstown

Nearby zip codes

12095

Similar homes

For Sale

$149,000

4 bd2 ba2,200 sqft

12 E Clinton Street, Johnstown, NY

For Sale

$179,900

4 bd3 ba2,844 sqft

101 E Main St, Johnstown, NY

For Sale

$195,000

4 bd2 ba2,020 sqft

107 Dove Street, Johnstown, NY

For Sale

$179,000

3 bd2 ba1,332 sqft

4 Oak Street, Johnstown, NY

For Sale

$140,000

4 bd2 ba2,116 sqft

20 Franklin Street, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$174,999

4 bd2 ba1,816 sqft

22 Eagle Street, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$220,000

4 bd2 ba1,900 sqft

204-206 Wells Street, Johnstown, NY

For Sale

$230,000

6 bd3 ba3,248 sqft

112 Pleasant Avenue, Johnstown, NY

For Sale

$159,900

4 bd3 ba1,550 sqft

104 Prospect Avenue, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$129,900

3 bd2 ba1,344 sqft

11 Leto Ln, Johnstown, NY

For Sale

$149,900

6 bd2 ba2,488 sqft

51 Division Street, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$220,000

6 bd2 ba2,162 sqft

87 Yale Street, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$189,000

4 bd2 ba2,250 sqft

99 6th Avenue, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$160,000

6 bd4 ba2,952 sqft

236 W Fulton Street, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$157,900

6 bd2 ba2,088 sqft

7 Smith St, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$199,500

5 bd2 ba2,676 sqft

17 2nd Avenue, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$165,000

3 bd2 ba1,632 sqft

269 Bleecker Street, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$199,900

4 bd2 ba2,216 sqft

258 Kingsboro Avenue, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$149,999

2 bd3 ba1,560 sqft

27 N McNab Avenue, Gloversville, NY

For Sale

$125,000

5 bd3 ba3,174 sqft

187 Bleecker Street, Gloversville, NY

Tour This Home

Pick a date

Preferred time

Mar 27, 2026

High demand — 453 people viewed this listing. Tours fill up fast.

No obligation · Same-day confirmation · Takes 30 seconds

Need a different time? Request custom scheduling

Have a Question?

Get details on this property, the neighborhood, or the buying process.

Ask About This Property

We typically respond within a few hours

Download property brochure

Photos, details & neighborhood info in one PDF

Get brochure

Free · No sign-up required

Get pre-approved

Know your budget & strengthen your offer

Check eligibility

Down Payment Assistance

Learn how to qualify

Value estimates

Live

Est. rent$1,477/mo

Affordability$1,184/mo

Own a home nearby?

See what it's worth in today's market

Get estimate

Schedule Tour Ask

No obligation · Same-day response