Sold380d on market
5520 Mayne Rd
East Bethany, NY, 14054 • 14054 • Genesee County
$350,000
$143/sqft
5Beds
4Baths
2,452Sqft
19.3 acLot
1975Built
Property DNA
Cape Cod Style
Built 1975 · 51 years of history
Special Features
Barn(s) · Outbuilding · Shed(s) · Storage
2-Car Garage
Attached · Electricity · Garage · Garage Door Opener
This home is getting attention
Listed 380 days ago · 9 views
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
9 views
People checking out this listing
380 days on market
Established listing
$143/sqft
Price per square foot
Selling Soon Prediction
HighThis home ranks in the top 28% of listings most likely to go under contract soon, based on market activity and demand signals.
Likelihood score
Want the full market analysis?
Get the detailed selling prediction score, comparable sales data, and price trend forecast for this property.
Free · Delivered to your inbox in minutes
About this home
Single Family · Built 1975
One-of-a-Kind, Residential Opportunity in a Great Location! This unique, custom-built home offers one-floor living with 3 finished bedrooms and 2.5 baths on the main level, plus the potential to finish 2 additional bedrooms and a bath upstairs to fit your style. The existing, first-floor primary suite could also be an in-law suite. The full basement, with newer mechanics (HTW 2019, Furnace 2021), is plumbed for yet another bath and ready to be transformed into more living space, recreation room, a workshop, or storage. The home features an attached 2-car garage and a detached 2-car outbuilding as well as a shed for extra workspace and storage. Enjoy two custom, stone, wood-burning fireplaces and a natural gas well with a transferable lease, providing free gas for the owner. Nestled on nearly 20 wooded acres, the property feels like a private retreat but is just minutes from major routes and less than 5 miles to the center of Batavia. Plus, public water is coming soon/confirmed for Water District 5, Town of Bethany! Located in the Pavilion School District, this is the perfect opportunity to create your dream home in a peaceful, country setting close to lifestyle conveniences. Bonus: potential to create an additional building lots on the Mayne Road frontage of the property.
Standout features identified
Our analysis highlights in-law suite, wooded acres, and one-floor living as key attractions of this home.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$2,171/month
Principal & Interest$1,705
Property Tax$350
Insurance$117
Down payment20% ($70,000)
3%50%
Est. 6.14% rate · 30yr fixed · $280,000 loan
Full calculator →At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeSingle Family Residence
Year Built1975
HeatingGas, Zoned, Baseboard, Forced Air
CoolingZoned
Parking2 Attached Garage spaces
Lot19.30 Acres
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Sub-typeSingle Family Residence
StyleCape Cod
ConditionResale
Year built1975
Systems
HeatingGas, Zoned, Baseboard, Forced Air
CoolingZoned
RoofAsphalt
ConstructionVinyl Siding, Copper Plumbing
Water / SewerWell / Septic Tank
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingAttached, Electricity, Garage, Garage Door Opener
Garage2 spaces
BasementFull,Sump Pump
Lot19.30 Acres
Location & Tax
Neighborhood14054
Annual tax$6,913
Parcel1828002173
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths3
Features & details
13 categories of property features
Interior Features
Interior
Bathroom Rough-In
Eat-in Kitchen
Great Room
Home Office
In-Law Floorplan
Main Level Primary
Primary Suite
Workshop
Appliances
Built-In Range
Built-In Oven
Double Oven
Dishwasher
Electric Cooktop
Electric Water Heater
Refrigerator
Water Softener Owned
Flooring
Carpet
Varies
Vinyl
Heating
Gas
Zoned
Baseboard
Forced Air
Cooling
Zoned
Laundry
In Basement
Windows
Thermal Windows
Exterior Features
Exterior
Gravel Driveway
Parking
Attached
Electricity
Garage
Garage Door Opener
Construction
Vinyl Siding
Copper Plumbing
Lot Features
Agricultural
Rectangular
Rectangular Lot
Rural Lot
Wooded
Utilities
Cable Available
Other Structures
Barn(s)
Outbuilding
Shed(s)
Storage
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusSold
Days on market380
Est. value$385,000
Est. rent$3,079/mo
Tax rate2.51%
Price/sqft$143
On marketFeb 6, 2025
PostedFeb 6, 2025
Last sold$350,000
MLS statusClosed
MLS updatedMar 25, 2025
Tour days6
Views9
How are the schools in East Bethany?
2 schools rated nearby
Location
East Bethany, NY, 14054
Price history
4 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Mar 24, 2025Sold$350,000$143NYSAMLSs
Feb 11, 2025Pending Sale$350,000$143NYSAMLSs
Feb 10, 2025Contingent$350,000$143NYSAMLSs
Feb 6, 2025Listed For Sale$350,000$143NYSAMLSs
Sold$350,000
Mar 24, 2025•$143/sqft•NYSAMLSs
Pending Sale$350,000
Feb 11, 2025•$143/sqft•NYSAMLSs
Contingent$350,000
Feb 10, 2025•$143/sqft•NYSAMLSs
Listed For Sale$350,000
Feb 6, 2025•$143/sqft•NYSAMLSs
Tax history
25 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 9, 2024—$254,500
Apr 9, 2023—$203,600
Apr 9, 2022—$203,600
Apr 9, 2021—$203,600
Apr 9, 2020—$177,000
Apr 9, 2019—$177,000
Apr 9, 2018—$177,000
Apr 9, 2017$4,542$177,000
Apr 9, 2016—$168,600
Apr 9, 2015—$168,600
Apr 9, 2014—$168,600
Apr 9, 2013—$163,700
Apr 9, 2012—$163,700
Apr 9, 2011—$163,700
Apr 9, 2010—$161,700
Apr 9, 2009—$161,700
Apr 9, 2008—$161,700
Apr 9, 2007—$126,400
Apr 9, 2006—$126,400
Apr 9, 2005—$126,400
Apr 9, 2004—$117,000
Apr 9, 2003—$117,000
Apr 9, 2002—$117,000
Apr 9, 2001—$114,000
Apr 9, 2000—$114,000
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
East Bethany, NY • Genesee County
Nearby cities
AldenArcadeAtticaBataviaBergenCorfuLe RoyOakfield
Nearby zip codes
1403914054
Similar homes
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, UNYREIS and WNYREIS. Real estate listings held by firms other than Zillow, Inc. are marked with the IDX logo and include the Listing Broker’s Firm Name. Listing Data last updated at 2026-04-09 07:50:37 PDT. Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither the listing broker(s) nor Zillow, Inc. shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. © 2026 CNYIS, UNYREIS, WNYREIS. All rights reserved.
No obligation · Same-day response