For Sale569d on marketHistoric · 131 yrs
23 Saint John St
Monticello, NY, 12701 • 12701 • Sullivan County
$285,000
$202/sqft
Down payment assistance available
2Beds
2Baths
1,408Sqft
0.11 acLot
1895Built
Property DNA
Character Home
Built 1895 · 131 years of history
Tile & Hardwood Floors
Quality flooring throughout
This home is getting attention
Listed 569 days ago · 438 views · 24 saves
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
438 views
People checking out this listing
24 saves
Buyers have saved this home
569 days on market
Established listing
$202/sqft
Price per square foot
Selling Soon Prediction
HighThis home ranks in the top 30% of listings most likely to go under contract soon, based on market activity and demand signals.
Likelihood score
Want the full market analysis?
Get the detailed selling prediction score, comparable sales data, and price trend forecast for this property.
Free · Delivered to your inbox in minutes
About this home
Single Family · Built 1895 · Historic
Warm and charming with its beamed ceilings, wide plank wood floors, big country kitchen, wood burning stove, fpl and more, as well as great curb appeal. Many newer upgrades over the years, must be seen.
Standout features identified
Our analysis highlights wide plank wooden floors, resorts casino, and beamed ceilings as key attractions of this home.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$1,772/month
Principal & Interest$1,392
Property Tax$285
Insurance$95
Down payment20% ($57,000)
3%50%
Est. 6.17% rate · 30yr fixed · $228,000 loan
Full calculator →At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeSingleFamily
Year Built1895
HeatingOther, Oil, Wood / Pellet
CoolingOther
Parking4 Parking spaces
Lot4,791 sqft
Days on Zillow569 Days
Price/sqft$202
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Year built1895
Systems
HeatingOther, Oil, Wood / Pellet
CoolingOther
RoofAsphalt
ConstructionWood
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingOff-street
BasementPartially finished
Lot4,791 sqft
Location & Tax
Neighborhood12701
Parcel48460111641
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths1
Features & details
7 categories of property features
Interior Features
Appliances
Dishwasher
Dryer
Microwave
Range / Oven
Refrigerator
Washer
Flooring
Tile
Other
Hardwood
Heating
Other
Oil
Wood / Pellet
Cooling
Other
Exterior Features
Exterior
Shingle
Stone
Wood
Parking
Off-street
Construction
Wood
Room details
3 rooms detailed
Walk In Closet
Family Room
Pantry
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusFor Sale
Days on market569
Est. rent$1,751/mo
Tax rate1.77%
Price/sqft$202
On marketSep 18, 2024
PostedSep 18, 2024
Last sold$38,000
Tour days6
Views438
Favorites24
How are the schools in Monticello?
3 schools rated nearby
Location
Monticello, NY, 12701
Price history
23 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Jan 30, 2026Listed For Sale$285,000$202Owner
Jan 14, 2026Listing Removed——Owner
Oct 16, 2025Price Change$285,000$202Owner
Sep 27, 2025Listed For Sale$275,000$195Owner
Sep 6, 2025Listing Removed——Owner
Jun 8, 2025Price Change$275,000$195Owner
Mar 18, 2025Price Change$259,000$184Owner
Jan 14, 2025Listed For Sale$260,000$185Owner
Dec 17, 2024Listing Removed——Owner
Sep 18, 2024Listed For Sale$260,000$185Owner
Aug 10, 2023Listing Removed——Owner
Feb 20, 2023Listed For Sale$250,000$178Owner
Oct 21, 2022Listing Removed——Owner
Jul 23, 2022Price Change$260,000$185Owner
Jun 20, 2022Listed For Sale$270,000$192Owner
Mar 24, 2021Listing Removed——Owner
Apr 14, 2014Listing Removed$125,000$89Owner
Oct 23, 2013Listed For Sale$125,000$89Owner
Apr 17, 2013Listing Removed$139,000$99Owner
Apr 23, 2012Listed For Sale$139,000$99Owner
Aug 29, 2011Listing Removed$139,000$99Owner
Mar 2, 2011Listed For Sale$139,000$99Owner
Jan 22, 2003Sold$38,000$27Public Record
Listed For Sale$285,000
Jan 30, 2026•$202/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed—
Jan 14, 2026•Owner
Price Change$285,000
Oct 16, 2025•$202/sqft•Owner
Listed For Sale$275,000
Sep 27, 2025•$195/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed—
Sep 6, 2025•Owner
Price Change$275,000
Jun 8, 2025•$195/sqft•Owner
Price Change$259,000
Mar 18, 2025•$184/sqft•Owner
Listed For Sale$260,000
Jan 14, 2025•$185/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed—
Dec 17, 2024•Owner
Listed For Sale$260,000
Sep 18, 2024•$185/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed—
Aug 10, 2023•Owner
Listed For Sale$250,000
Feb 20, 2023•$178/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed—
Oct 21, 2022•Owner
Price Change$260,000
Jul 23, 2022•$185/sqft•Owner
Listed For Sale$270,000
Jun 20, 2022•$192/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed—
Mar 24, 2021•Owner
Listing Removed$125,000
Apr 14, 2014•$89/sqft•Owner
Listed For Sale$125,000
Oct 23, 2013•$89/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed$139,000
Apr 17, 2013•$99/sqft•Owner
Listed For Sale$139,000
Apr 23, 2012•$99/sqft•Owner
Listing Removed$139,000
Aug 29, 2011•$99/sqft•Owner
Listed For Sale$139,000
Mar 2, 2011•$99/sqft•Owner
Sold$38,000
Jan 22, 2003•$27/sqft•Public Record
Tax history
26 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 11, 2025—$68,100
Apr 11, 2024—$68,100
Apr 11, 2023—$68,100
Apr 11, 2022—$68,100
Apr 11, 2021—$68,100
Apr 11, 2020—$68,100
Apr 11, 2019—$68,100
Apr 11, 2018—$68,100
Apr 11, 2017$2,549$68,100
Apr 11, 2016—$68,100
Apr 11, 2015—$68,100
Apr 11, 2014—$68,100
Apr 11, 2013—$68,100
Apr 11, 2012—$68,100
Apr 11, 2011—$68,100
Apr 11, 2010—$68,100
Apr 11, 2009—$68,100
Apr 11, 2008—$68,100
Apr 11, 2007—$68,100
Apr 11, 2006—$68,100
Apr 11, 2005—$68,100
Apr 11, 2004—$68,100
Apr 11, 2003—$56,800
Apr 11, 2002—$56,800
Apr 11, 2001—$56,800
Apr 11, 2000—$56,800
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Monticello, NY • Sullivan County
Nearby neighborhoods
Bridgeville
Nearby cities
BloomingburgCallicoonHurleyvilleLibertyLivingston ManorMonticelloRock HillRoscoe
Nearby zip codes
1270112784
Similar homes
No obligation · Same-day response