Off Market6933d on market

251 Plymouth Dr

Bay Village, OH, 44140 • 44140 • Cuyahoga County

$895,700

$198/sqft

4Beds

3.5Baths

4,522Sqft

0.79 acLot

1961Built

Property DNA

1 highlights

Colonial Style

Built 1961 · 65 years of history

Market activity

Demand and pricing signals for this listing

9 views

People checking out this listing

6933 days on market

Established listing

$198/sqft

Price per square foot

About this home

Single Family · Built 1961

This 4522 square foot single family home has 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms. This home is located at 251 Plymouth Dr, Bay Village, OH 44140.

Estimated monthly payment

Based on current rates

$5,601/month

Principal & Interest$4,406

Property Tax$896

Insurance$299

Down payment20% ($179,140)

3%50%

Est. 6.24% rate · 30yr fixed · $716,560 loan

Full calculator →

At a glance

Key facts and listing details

TypeSingleFamily

Year Built1961

HeatingForced air

CoolingCentral

Parking2 Parking spaces

Lot0.79 Acres

Property

Home typeSingle Family

StyleColonial

Year built1961

Systems

HeatingForced air

CoolingCentral

RoofAsphalt

ConstructionFrame

Parking & Outdoor

ParkingCarport, Garage - Attached

BasementPartially finished

Lot0.79 Acres

Location & Tax

Neighborhood44140

Annual tax$16,634

Parcel20114044

Features & details

5 categories of property features

Interior Features

Heating

Forced air

Cooling

Central

Exterior Features

Exterior

Other

Wood

Parking

Carport

Garage - Attached

Construction

Frame

Listing insights

Market data and value estimates

StatusOff Market

Days on market6933

Est. value$895,700

Est. rent$4,038/mo

Tax rate1.92%

Price/sqft$198

Last sold$394,000

Tour days6

How are the schools in Bay Village?

3 schools rated nearby

Westerly Elementary School

Elementary • Public • 3-4

0.9 mi

Bay Middle School

Elementary • Public • 5-8

2.2 mi

Bay High School

High • Public • 9-12

1.4 mi

Location

Bay Village, OH, 44140

Expand map

Price history

2 events

DateEventPrice$/sqftSource

Apr 16, 2007Sold$394,000$87Public Record

Aug 16, 2005Sold$358,000$79MLS Now

Sold$394,000

Apr 16, 2007•$87/sqft•Public Record

Sold$358,000

Aug 16, 2005•$79/sqft•MLS Now

Tax history

25 years of records

YearTax paidAssessed value

Apr 10, 2024$16,634$245,460

Apr 10, 2023$15,341$191,770

Apr 10, 2022$15,269$191,770

Apr 10, 2021$13,837$191,770

Apr 10, 2020$13,152$163,910

Apr 10, 2019$13,081$163,900

Apr 10, 2018$12,982$163,910

Apr 10, 2017$11,857$136,050

Apr 10, 2016$10,733$135,000

Apr 10, 2015$10,733$135,000

Apr 10, 2014$10,342$124,990

Apr 10, 2013$10,233$124,990

Apr 10, 2012$10,113$123,520

Apr 10, 2011$964$121,000

Apr 10, 2010$9,636$121,000

Apr 10, 2009$8,924$121,000

Apr 10, 2008$8,533$118,410

Apr 10, 2007$8,132$118,410

Apr 10, 2006$8,274$118,410

Apr 10, 2005$7,002$102,340

Apr 10, 2004$6,828$102,340

Apr 10, 2003$6,720$102,340

Apr 10, 2002$5,851$90,160

Apr 10, 2001$11,820$90,160

Apr 10, 2000$11,820$90,160

Nearby homes

Off Market

$1,261,000

5 bd5 ba5,355 sqft

257 Plymouth Dr, Bay Village, OH

Off Market

$904,400

4 bd1.5 ba3,816 sqft

31429 Nantucket Row, Bay Village, OH

Off Market

$911,800

5 bd2 ba3,300 sqft

31417 Nantucket Row, Bay Village, OH

Off Market

$425,300

4 bd2 ba2,014 sqft

31418 Walker Rd, Bay Village, OH

Off Market

$384,400

3 bd1 ba1,959 sqft

31426 Walker Rd, Bay Village, OH

Off Market

$668,600

4 bd2 ba3,994 sqft

31403 Nantucket Row, Bay Village, OH

Off Market

$434,600

3 bd1.5 ba1,980 sqft

31434 Walker Rd, Bay Village, OH

Off Market

$406,300

3 bd1.5 ba1,558 sqft

31406 Walker Rd, Bay Village, OH

Neighborhood details

Local context around this listing

Bay Village, OH • Cuyahoga County

Nearby cities

ClevelandCleveland HeightsEuclidGarfield HeightsLakewoodNorth OlmstedNorth RoyaltonParma

Nearby zip codes

44140

Similar homes

For Sale

$899,000

4 bd4 ba5,548 sqft

1542 Glen Lyon Dr, Westlake, OH

For Sale

$775,000

5 bd4 ba4,519 sqft

607 Parkside Dr, Avon Lake, OH

For Sale

$950,000

4 bd4 ba4,041 sqft

30611 Winston Dr, Bay Village, OH

For Sale

$649,900

4 bd4 ba2,812 sqft

25301 Wolf Rd, Bay Village, OH

For Sale

$774,900

3 bd3 ba2,491 sqft

31523 Pier E, Avon Lake, OH

33445 Reserve Way At Street Andrews, Avon, OH

For Sale

$900,000

5 bd5 ba4,387 sqft

33445 Reserve Way At Street Andrews, Avon, OH

For Sale

$599,900

4 bd3 ba2,636 sqft

620 Lindford Dr, Bay Village, OH

For Sale

$870,000

5 bd5 ba3,892 sqft

32341 Regency Ct, Avon Lake, OH

For Sale

$950,000

4 bd5 ba3,699 sqft

1800 Bur Oak Dr, Westlake, OH

For Sale

$949,900

4 bd5 ba3,409 sqft

32811 Saint James Trl, Avon, OH

For Sale

$1,199,900

4 bd5 ba6,543 sqft

3146 Regency Pl, Westlake, OH

For Sale

$525,000

3 bd4 ba3,076 sqft

598 Chancellor Cir, Avon Lake, OH

For Sale

$875,000

5 bd3 ba3,350 sqft

509 Forecastle Ct, Avon Lake, OH

For Sale

$800,000

4 bd3 ba3,802 sqft

2366 Bradley Rd, Westlake, OH

For Sale

$900,000

3 bd4 ba4,587 sqft

33452 Santa Marie Ct, Avon, OH

For Sale

$799,900

4 bd3 ba2,506 sqft

362 Oakmoor Rd, Bay Village, OH

For Sale

$681,900

4 bd3 ba2,500 sqft

406 The Inlt, Avon Lake, OH

For Sale

4 bd4 ba3,116 sqft

33649 Saint Francis Dr, Avon, OH

For Sale

$804,900

4 bd4 ba3,435 sqft

S/l 17 Autumn Ct, Avon, OH

For Sale

$509,000

4 bd3 ba2,296 sqft

208 Westwind Dr, Avon Lake, OH

Tour This Home

Pick a date

Preferred time

Apr 10, 2026

No obligation · Same-day confirmation · Takes 30 seconds

Need a different time? Request custom scheduling

Have a Question?

Get details on this property, the neighborhood, or the buying process.

Ask About This Property

We typically respond within a few hours

Download property brochure

Photos, details & neighborhood info in one PDF

Get brochure

Free · No sign-up required

Get pre-approved

Know your budget & strengthen your offer

Check eligibility

Value estimates

Live

Est. value$895,700

Est. rent$4,038/mo

30yr rate est.6.24%

Affordability$6,024/mo

Own a home nearby?

See what it's worth in today's market

Get estimate

Schedule Tour Ask

No obligation · Same-day response