Sold235d on marketHistoric · 151 yrs
9980 Lancaster Newark Rd NE
Baltimore, OH, 43105 • 43105 • Fairfield County
$240,000
$65/sqft
3,672Sqft
1 acLot
1875Built
Property DNA
Character Home
Built 1875 · 151 years of history
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
16 views
People checking out this listing
1 saves
Buyers have saved this home
235 days on market
Established listing
$65/sqft
Price per square foot
About this home
Single Family · Built 1875 · Historic
RARE FIND! This 1875 historic church is the opportunity of a lifetime to transform into your dream home. Located on the corner of Lancaster Newark Rd and Bickel Church Rd on 1.2 serene acres. A few of the many updates include 2019 -24 gauge metal roof with matching gutters. New fiber cement soffits, facia, garage siding and bell tower. New Amish built custom 8ft tall solid front door with side lights. New custom round window rebuilt to original bell tower. Repair and tuck point much of exterior brick and sandstone. New coat of paint on all exterior non-masonry surfaces on exterior. New concrete driveway. New dry stack limestone flowerbeds. 2013- New vinyl replacement windows. This property is definitely a Must See property.
Standout features identified
Our analysis highlights serene acres, custom round window, and new coat of paint as key attractions of this home.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$1,585/month
Principal & Interest$1,265
Property Tax$240
Insurance$80
Down payment20% ($48,000)
3%50%
Est. 6.90% rate · 30yr fixed · $192,000 loan
Full calculator →At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeSingle Family Residence
Year Built1875
Parking2 Covered Parking spaces
Lot1.02 Acres
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Sub-typeSingle Family Residence
ConditionTo Be Built
Year built1875
Systems
Water / SewerPrivate / Private Sewer
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingGarage
Garage2 spaces
Lot1.02 Acres
Location & Tax
Neighborhood43105
Annual tax$4,080
Parcel0490249900
Features & details
2 categories of property features
Interior Features
Windows
Insulated Windows
Exterior Features
Parking
Garage
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusSold
Days on market235
Est. rent$1,774/mo
Tax rate1.14%
Price/sqft$65
On marketJul 1, 2025
PostedMay 6, 2024
Last sold$240,000
MLS updatedAug 15, 2025
Tour days6
Views16
Favorites1
How are the schools in Baltimore?
3 schools rated nearby
Location
Baltimore, OH, 43105
Price history
16 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Aug 15, 2025Sold$240,000$65Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Jul 16, 2025Contingent$265,000$72Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Jul 1, 2025Listed For Sale$265,000$72Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Jun 18, 2025Pending Sale$265,000$72Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Nov 4, 2024Price Change$265,000$72Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Jul 24, 2024Price Change$279,900$76Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
May 6, 2024Listed For Sale$299,900$82Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Nov 16, 2023Listing Removed——Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Aug 24, 2023Listed For Sale$299,900$82Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Aug 5, 2023Pending Sale$299,900$82Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Jul 26, 2023Price Change$299,900$82Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Jun 22, 2023Price Change$349,900$95Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
May 16, 2023Listed For Sale$389,900$106Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Jan 16, 2023Listing Removed——Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Sep 16, 2022Price Change$399,900$109Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Aug 22, 2022Listed For Sale$425,000$116Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Sold$240,000
Aug 15, 2025•$65/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Contingent$265,000
Jul 16, 2025•$72/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listed For Sale$265,000
Jul 1, 2025•$72/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Pending Sale$265,000
Jun 18, 2025•$72/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Price Change$265,000
Nov 4, 2024•$72/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Price Change$279,900
Jul 24, 2024•$76/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listed For Sale$299,900
May 6, 2024•$82/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listing Removed—
Nov 16, 2023•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listed For Sale$299,900
Aug 24, 2023•$82/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Pending Sale$299,900
Aug 5, 2023•$82/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Price Change$299,900
Jul 26, 2023•$82/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Price Change$349,900
Jun 22, 2023•$95/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listed For Sale$389,900
May 16, 2023•$106/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listing Removed—
Jan 16, 2023•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Price Change$399,900
Sep 16, 2022•$109/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listed For Sale$425,000
Aug 22, 2022•$116/sqft•Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Tax history
25 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 8, 2024$60$1,580
Apr 8, 2023$60$1,580
Apr 8, 2022$59$1,580
Apr 8, 2021$54$1,320
Apr 8, 2020$54$1,320
Apr 8, 2019$56$1,320
Apr 8, 2018$277$5,990
Apr 8, 2017$279$5,990
Apr 8, 2016$257$5,990
Apr 8, 2015$261$5,990
Apr 8, 2014$250$5,990
Apr 8, 2013$248$5,990
Apr 8, 2012$1,290$5,990
Apr 8, 2011$1,290$31,470
Apr 8, 2010$1,263$31,470
Apr 8, 2009$1,170$29,220
Apr 8, 2008$1,152$29,211
Apr 8, 2007$1,171$31,465
Apr 8, 2006$1,047$27,185
Apr 8, 2005$981$27,185
Apr 8, 2004$933$27,185
Apr 8, 2003$892$26,394
Apr 8, 2002$901$26,394
Apr 8, 2001$807$26,394
Apr 8, 2000$710$22,418
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Baltimore, OH • Fairfield County
Nearby cities
AmandaBaltimoreBremenCanal WinchesterCarrollLancasterMillersportPickerington
Nearby zip codes
43105
Similar homes
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
No obligation · Same-day response