Sold846d on marketHistoric · 125 yrs
2354 New Milford Rd
Atwater, OH, 44201 • 44201 • Portage County
$203,500
$123/sqft
5Beds
1Baths
1,654Sqft
4.2 acLot
1901Built
Property DNA
Colonial Style
Built 1901 · 125 years of history
Outdoor Living
Enclosed · Patio · Porch
This home is getting attention
Listed 846 days ago · 5 views
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
5 views
People checking out this listing
846 days on market
Established listing
$123/sqft
Price per square foot
Selling Soon Prediction
HighThis home ranks in the top 19% of listings most likely to go under contract soon, based on market activity and demand signals.
Likelihood score
Want the full market analysis?
Get the detailed selling prediction score, comparable sales data, and price trend forecast for this property.
Free · Delivered to your inbox in minutes
About this home
Single Family · Built 1901 · Historic
Motivated Sellers! Attention all horse/farm lovers! Plenty of room to roam on this 1,654 sq ft colonial farmhouse built in 1901 with 5 bedrooms, 1 bath horse property perfectly located on 4.2 acres in Randolph Township! New (2022) 24x35 barn with 2 stalls, a chicken coop, work area, storage loft, electric and water. There are also 2 additional outbuildings on the property - additional 40x30 barn (in need of some repairs) and an additional 12x8 chicken coop (Please do not touch electric fence!) Home features on the first floor are- 2 bedrooms on the first floor with nice sized closets, spacious eat in kitchen (stove, fridge and microwave convey), large living room with new carpet (2023) and your full bathroom with new flooring and extra deep storage cubby. Second floor you will find your additional 3 bedrooms with nice size closets (one has a beautiful cedar closet). You will find your laundry room in the basement along with plenty of room for storage. On your spacious 4.2 acres of property, you will also enjoy grape vines, pear trees and apple trees! There is also a nice big fenced in area for your dogs to also enjoy being outside with you! You don’t want to miss out on your opportunity to make this home yours. Call your favorite realtor to schedule your private viewing before this property is gone! Home has security cameras but audio has been turned off.
Standout features identified
Our analysis highlights nice sized closets, nice size closets, and spacious eat in kitchen as key attractions of this home.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$1,341/month
Principal & Interest$1,069
Property Tax$204
Insurance$68
Down payment20% ($40,700)
3%50%
Est. 6.88% rate · 30yr fixed · $162,800 loan
Full calculator →At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeSingle Family Residence
Year Built1901
HeatingForced Air, Oil
CoolingWindow Unit(s)
ParkingNo Garage, Unpaved
Lot4.20 Acres
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Sub-typeSingle Family Residence
StyleColonial
Year built1901
Stories2
Systems
HeatingForced Air, Oil
CoolingWindow Unit(s)
RoofAsphalt,Fiberglass
ConstructionWood Siding
Water / SewerWell / Septic Tank
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingNo Garage, Unpaved
BasementFull,Unfinished
FencingOther
Lot4.20 Acres
Location & Tax
Neighborhood44201
Annual tax$2,425
Parcel280820000007000
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths1
Features & details
7 categories of property features
Interior Features
Appliances
Microwave
Range
Refrigerator
Heating
Forced Air
Oil
Cooling
Window Unit(s)
Exterior Features
Parking
No Garage
Unpaved
Construction
Wood Siding
Patio & Porch
Enclosed
Patio
Porch
Lot Features
Horse Property
Room details
9 rooms detailed
Master Bedroom
First12.3×14.1 ft
Bedroom
First11.2×8.9 ft
Bedroom
Second11.2×9.4 ft
Bedroom
Second11.5×15 ft
Bedroom
Second11.4×15 ft
Bathroom
First11.1×8.1 ft
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusSold
Days on market846
Est. value$250,100
Est. rent$2,288/mo
Tax rate1.19%
Price/sqft$123
On marketSep 26, 2023
PostedSep 26, 2023
Last sold$203,500
MLS updatedDec 15, 2023
Tour days6
Views5
How are the schools in Atwater?
3 schools rated nearby
Location
Atwater, OH, 44201
Price history
8 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Dec 13, 2023Sold$203,500$123MLS Now
Nov 28, 2023Pending Sale$205,000$124MLS Now
Nov 5, 2023Contingent$205,000$124MLS Now
Oct 22, 2023Price Change$205,000$124MLS Now
Oct 9, 2023Price Change$224,900$136MLS Now
Sep 26, 2023Listed For Sale$239,900$145MLS Now
Oct 2, 2009Sold$115,000$70MLS Now
Apr 26, 2009Listed For Sale$129,900$79Cutler Real Estate
Sold$203,500
Dec 13, 2023•$123/sqft•MLS Now
Pending Sale$205,000
Nov 28, 2023•$124/sqft•MLS Now
Contingent$205,000
Nov 5, 2023•$124/sqft•MLS Now
Price Change$205,000
Oct 22, 2023•$124/sqft•MLS Now
Price Change$224,900
Oct 9, 2023•$136/sqft•MLS Now
Listed For Sale$239,900
Sep 26, 2023•$145/sqft•MLS Now
Sold$115,000
Oct 2, 2009•$70/sqft•MLS Now
Listed For Sale$129,900
Apr 26, 2009•$79/sqft•Cutler Real Estate
Tax history
24 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 8, 2024$2,469$63,640
Apr 8, 2023$2,439$53,590
Apr 8, 2022$2,425$52,010
Apr 8, 2021$2,431$52,010
Apr 8, 2020$2,138$46,310
Apr 8, 2019$2,153$46,310
Apr 8, 2018$1,784$38,160
Apr 8, 2017$1,784$38,160
Apr 8, 2016$1,780$38,160
Apr 8, 2015$1,800$38,160
Apr 8, 2014$1,790$36,760
Apr 8, 2013$1,736$36,760
Apr 8, 2012$1,542$36,760
Apr 8, 2011$1,290$31,430
Apr 8, 2010$1,278$31,430
Apr 8, 2009$1,269$31,360
Apr 8, 2008$1,269$31,360
Apr 8, 2005$1,106—
Apr 8, 2004$1,116—
Apr 8, 2003$1,069—
Apr 8, 2002$1,020—
Apr 8, 2001$2,447—
Apr 8, 2000$2,474—
Apr 8, 1999$1,929—
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Atwater, OH • Portage County
Nearby cities
AtwaterAuroraGarrettsvilleKentMantuaMogadoreNewton FallsRavenna
Nearby zip codes
4420144272
Similar homes
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS NOW. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Zillow, Inc. are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s). Zillow, Inc. does not display the entire MLS NOW IDX database on this website. The listings of some real estate brokerage firms have been excluded. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright 2026 - Multiple Listing Service, Inc. – All Rights Reserved.
No obligation · Same-day response