Off Market1823d on marketHistoric · 126 yrs

51 Smullen St

Sayreville, NJ, 08872 • MacArthur Manor • Middlesex County

$558,600

$294/sqft

3Beds

2Baths

1,900Sqft

0.11 acLot

1900Built

Property DNA

3 highlights

Victorian Style

Built 1900 · 126 years of history

Outdoor Living

Porch

Hardwood Floors

Quality flooring throughout

Market activity

Demand and pricing signals for this listing

5 views

People checking out this listing

1823 days on market

Established listing

$294/sqft

Price per square foot

About this home

Single Family · Built 1900 · Historic

1 YEAR WARRANTY. Gorgeous Victorian style brick home with all the updates! Everything is new and remodeled. This beautiful home has 3 floors of living space with 2 updated bathrooms, 4 ample size bedrooms and finished attic. Beautiful quartz counters brand new S/S appliances, peninsula with plenty white shaker cabinet area make this kitchen a delight with an eating area that opens up to a great front deck and views of your neighborhood on a quiet street. The 9'ceilings in the living area, and formal dining rooms,all freshly painted in colors of today,spacious and airy rooms make this outstanding big home feel even larger.This home has two-zone brand new HVAC system.Beautiful hardwood floor throughout.A detached garage with a long driveway provides parking for 4-5 cars.Fenced backyard with a roofed patio provides place for entertainment as well as privacy.Located in the heart of Sayreville Conveniently located near top local attractions like Si Mangia restaurant,Bar,park,lake

Estimated monthly payment

Based on current rates

$3,491/month

Principal & Interest$2,746

Property Tax$559

Insurance$186

Down payment20% ($111,720)

3%50%

Est. 6.23% rate · 30yr fixed · $446,880 loan

Full calculator →

At a glance

Key facts and listing details

TypeSingleFamily

Year Built1900

HeatingForced air, Electric, Gas

CoolingCentral

Parking1 Parking space

Lot4,948 sqft

Property

Home typeSingle Family

StyleVictorian

Year built1900

Systems

HeatingForced air, Electric, Gas

CoolingCentral

RoofAsphalt

Water / SewerPublic / Public Sewer

Parking & Outdoor

ParkingGarage - Detached

BasementFull, Exterior Entry, Utility Room, Interior Entry

Lot4,948 sqft

Location & Tax

NeighborhoodMacArthur Manor

Annual tax$9,371

Parcel1900154000000022

Bathrooms & Fees

Full baths2

Features & details

11 categories of property features

Interior Features

Interior

Kitchen

Bath Other

Attic

4 Bedrooms

Bath Second

Appliances

Dishwasher

Microwave

Range / Oven

Flooring

Hardwood

Heating

Forced air

Electric

Gas

Cooling

Central

Accessibility

Stall Shower

Exterior Features

Exterior

Brick

Parking

Garage - Detached

Patio & Porch

Porch

Lot Features

Near Shopping

Near Public Transit

Corner Lot

Utilities

Electricity Connected

Natural Gas Connected

Underground Utilities

Room details

1 room detailed

Dining Room

Listing insights

Market data and value estimates

StatusOff Market

Days on market1823

Est. value$558,600

Est. rent$3,126/mo

Tax rate1.82%

Price/sqft$294

Last sold$396,000

Tour days6

How are the schools in Sayreville?

3 schools rated nearby

Wilson Elementary School

Elementary • Public • K-3

0.2 mi

Sayreville Middle School

Middle • Public • 6-8

1.9 mi

War Memorial High School

High • Public • 9-12

2.2 mi

Location

Sayreville, NJ, 08872

Expand map

Price history

18 events

DateEventPrice$/sqftSource

Apr 12, 2021Sold$396,000$208Public Record

Jan 8, 2021Sold$396,000$208All Jersey MLS

Dec 25, 2020Contingent$396,000$208All Jersey MLS

Dec 5, 2020Pending Sale$396,000$208FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Nov 19, 2020Listed For Sale$396,000$208FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Nov 15, 2020Pending Sale$396,000$208FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Oct 30, 2020Price Change$396,000$208FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Oct 7, 2020Pending Sale$399,900$210FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Sep 5, 2020Price Change$399,900$210FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Aug 25, 2020Price Change$409,900$216FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Aug 18, 2020Listed For Sale$415,000$218RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Jul 30, 2020Pending Sale$415,000$218RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Jul 21, 2020Price Change$415,000$218RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Jul 15, 2020Price Change$430,000$226RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Jul 7, 2020Listed For Sale$445,000$234RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Feb 13, 2020Sold$237,000$125Public Record

Jan 15, 2020Pending Sale$250,000$132RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Jan 9, 2020Listed For Sale$250,000$132RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Sold$396,000

Apr 12, 2021•$208/sqft•Public Record

Sold$396,000

Jan 8, 2021•$208/sqft•All Jersey MLS

Contingent$396,000

Dec 25, 2020•$208/sqft•All Jersey MLS

Pending Sale$396,000

Dec 5, 2020•$208/sqft•FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Listed For Sale$396,000

Nov 19, 2020•$208/sqft•FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Pending Sale$396,000

Nov 15, 2020•$208/sqft•FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Price Change$396,000

Oct 30, 2020•$208/sqft•FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Pending Sale$399,900

Oct 7, 2020•$210/sqft•FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Price Change$399,900

Sep 5, 2020•$210/sqft•FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Price Change$409,900

Aug 25, 2020•$216/sqft•FORMULA REALTY, LLC

Listed For Sale$415,000

Aug 18, 2020•$218/sqft•RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Pending Sale$415,000

Jul 30, 2020•$218/sqft•RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Price Change$415,000

Jul 21, 2020•$218/sqft•RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Price Change$430,000

Jul 15, 2020•$226/sqft•RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Listed For Sale$445,000

Jul 7, 2020•$234/sqft•RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Sold$237,000

Feb 13, 2020•$125/sqft•Public Record

Pending Sale$250,000

Jan 15, 2020•$132/sqft•RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Listed For Sale$250,000

Jan 9, 2020•$132/sqft•RE/MAX FIRST REALTY, INC.

Tax history

25 years of records

YearTax paidAssessed value

Apr 10, 2025$9,371$153,500

Apr 10, 2024$9,371$153,500

Apr 10, 2023$9,112$153,500

Apr 10, 2022$8,512$153,500

Apr 10, 2021$6,893$125,700

Apr 10, 2020$6,719$125,700

Apr 10, 2019$6,460$125,700

Apr 10, 2018$6,460$125,700

Apr 10, 2017$6,142$125,700

Apr 10, 2016$6,002$125,700

Apr 10, 2015$5,841$125,700

Apr 10, 2014$5,771$125,700

Apr 10, 2013$5,651$125,700

Apr 10, 2012$5,531$125,700

Apr 10, 2011$5,341$125,700

Apr 10, 2010$5,274$125,700

Apr 10, 2009$5,018$125,700

Apr 10, 2008—$125,700

Apr 10, 2007—$125,700

Apr 10, 2006—$125,700

Apr 10, 2005—$125,700

Apr 10, 2004$4,136$125,700

Apr 10, 2003—$125,700

Apr 10, 2002—$125,700

Apr 10, 2001—$125,700

Nearby homes

Off Market

$571,000

49 Smullen St, Sayreville, NJ

Off Market

$469,000

1,654 sqft

53 Smullen St, Sayreville, NJ

Off Market

$518,600

3 bd2 ba1,600 sqft

9 Mary St, Sayreville, NJ

Off Market

$495,600

1,489 sqft

55 Smullen St, Sayreville, NJ

Off Market

$500,300

31 Church St, Sayreville, NJ

31-41 Church St UNIT 303, South Orange, NJ

Off Market

$419,900

2 bd2 ba1,183 sqft

31-41 Church St UNIT 303, South Orange, NJ

31-41 Church St UNIT 304, South Orange, NJ

Off Market

$370,600

1 bd2 ba1,150 sqft

31-41 Church St UNIT 304, South Orange, NJ

31-41 Church St UNIT 306, South Orange, NJ

Off Market

$575,200

2 bd2 ba1,183 sqft

31-41 Church St UNIT 306, South Orange, NJ

Neighborhood details

Local context around this listing

Sayreville, NJ • Middlesex County

Nearby neighborhoods

CrossmansGillespieMacArthur ManorSayreville Station

Nearby cities

CarteretEast BrunswickEdisonMatawanMonroe TownshipNew BrunswickNorth BrunswickOld Bridge

Nearby zip codes

0887108872

Similar homes

For Sale

$450,000

3 bd2 ba1,288 sqft

53 Dane St, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$599,000

3 bd2 ba1,428 sqft

6 Thomas St, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

3 bd2 ba1,334 sqft

6 Schmitt St, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$721,000

4 bd2 ba2,548 sqft

176 Washington Rd, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$649,900

3 bd2 ba1,945 sqft

34 Douglas St, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$499,000

4 bd3 ba1,382 sqft

11 Pershing Ave, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$549,900

3 bd2 ba1,592 sqft

126 Prentice Ave, South River, NJ

For Sale

$687,000

3 bd2 ba1,368 sqft

46 N Edward St, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$649,900

3 bd2 ba1,508 sqft

54 Price St, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$499,000

4 bd3 ba1,682 sqft

7 Sheinfine Ave, South River, NJ

For Sale

$549,000

4 bd2 ba1,720 sqft

5 Northside Ave, South River, NJ

For Sale

$595,000

3 bd2 ba1,500 sqft

10 North Dr, East Brunswick, NJ

For Sale

$430,000

3 bd3 ba1,406 sqft

43 Lantern Ln, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$535,000

3 bd2 ba1,355 sqft

13 Bissett Pl, South River, NJ

For Sale

$424,000

3 bd1 ba1,004 sqft

39 Harrison St, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$500,000

4 bd1 ba1,404 sqft

42 Burton Ave, South River, NJ

For Sale

$550,000

3 bd2 ba1,064 sqft

894 Route 9, South Amboy, NJ

For Sale

$550,000

3 bd2 ba1,064 sqft

894 Route 9 Hwy, South Amboy, NJ

For Sale

$760,000

5 bd3 ba2,719 sqft

33 Nickel Ave, Sayreville, NJ

For Sale

$799,000

4 bd3 ba2,532 sqft

13 Skurka Ct, Sayreville, NJ

Tour This Home

Pick a date

Preferred time

Apr 10, 2026

No obligation · Same-day confirmation · Takes 30 seconds

Need a different time? Request custom scheduling

Have a Question?

Get details on this property, the neighborhood, or the buying process.

Ask About This Property

We typically respond within a few hours

Download property brochure

Photos, details & neighborhood info in one PDF

Get brochure

Free · No sign-up required

Get pre-approved

Know your budget & strengthen your offer

Check eligibility

Value estimates

Live

Est. value$558,600

Est. rent$3,126/mo

30yr rate est.6.23%

Affordability$3,709/mo

Own a home nearby?

See what it's worth in today's market

Get estimate

Schedule Tour Ask

No obligation · Same-day response