For Sale6d on marketHistoric · 123 yrs
96 Carey Ave
Butler, NJ, 07405 • 07405 • Morris County
$599,900
Down payment assistance available
3Beds
2Baths
0.22 acLot
1903Built
Property DNA
Colonial Style
Built 1903 · 123 years of history
Outdoor Living
Patio
2-Car Garage
2 Car Width · Asphalt · Attached Garage · Finished Garage · Loft Storage
Tile Floors
Quality flooring throughout
This home is getting attention
Listed 6 days ago · 2,320 views · 208 saves
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
2,320 views
People checking out this listing
208 saves
Buyers have saved this home
6 days on market
Just listed — act fast
About this home
Single Family · Built 1903 · Historic
Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath Colonial nestled on a quiet dead-end street in Butler. Offering the perfect blend of comfort, space, and convenience, this inviting home is ideal for today's lifestyle. Step inside to an open and airy floor plan designed for both everyday living and effortless entertaining. The seamless flow between the living, dining, and kitchen areas creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere filled with natural light. Upstairs, you'll find three well-appointed bedrooms along with a newly added full bath, thoughtfully designed for both comfort and functionality. A standout feature of the home is the versatile loft space above the two-car garage perfect for a home office, gym, or playroom. Outside, enjoy a spacious backyard ideal for hosting gatherings, summer barbecues, or simply relaxing in your own private retreat. Additional highlights include a newer roof (2023) and updated kitchen appliances. Conveniently located near schools, shopping, and major highways, this home offers the perfect balance of tranquility and accessibility. Don't miss this fantastic opportunity to own a beautiful home in a desirable neighborhood!
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$3,715/month
Principal & Interest$2,915
Property Tax$600
Insurance$200
Down payment20% ($119,980)
3%50%
Est. 6.12% rate · 30yr fixed · $479,920 loan
Full calculator →At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeSingle Family Residence
Year Built1903
Heating1 Unit, Baseboard - Hotwater, Zoned, Natural Gas
CoolingCeiling Fan(s), Window Unit(s)
Parking2 Attached Garage spaces
Lot9,583 sqft
Days on Zillow6 Days
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Sub-typeSingle Family Residence
StyleColonial
Year built1903
Systems
Heating1 Unit, Baseboard - Hotwater, Zoned, Natural Gas
CoolingCeiling Fan(s), Window Unit(s)
RoofAsphalt Shingle
ConstructionComposition Siding, Vinyl Siding
Water / SewerPublic / Public Sewer
Parking & Outdoor
Parking2 Car Width, Asphalt, Attached Garage, Finished Garage, Loft Storage
Garage2 spaces
BasementYes,Full,Unfinished
Lot9,583 sqft
Location & Tax
Neighborhood07405
Annual tax$11,909
Parcel0300007000000024
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths2
Features & details
12 categories of property features
Interior Features
Interior
Bathroom
Loft
Appliances
Carbon Monoxide Detector
Dishwasher
Dryer
Range/Oven-Gas
Refrigerator
Washer
Gas Water Heater
Flooring
Laminate
Tile
Heating
1 Unit
Baseboard - Hotwater
Zoned
Natural Gas
Cooling
Ceiling Fan(s)
Window Unit(s)
Laundry
In Basement
Exterior Features
Parking
2 Car Width
Asphalt
Attached Garage
Finished Garage
Loft Storage
Construction
Composition Siding
Vinyl Siding
Patio & Porch
Patio
Security
Carbon Monoxide Detector
Utilities
Electricity Connected
Natural Gas Connected
Cable Connected
Garbage Included
Gas
Gas-Natural
Room details
8 rooms detailed
Bedroom1
SecondBedroom2
SecondBedroom3
SecondDining Room
FirstFormal Dining Room
Family Room
FirstKitchen
FirstEat-in Kitchen
Listing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusFor Sale
Days on market6
Est. value$540,300
Est. rent$3,094/mo
Tax rate1.80%
On marketApr 11, 2026
PostedApr 8, 2026
Last sold$360,500
MLS statusActive
MLS updatedApr 10, 2026
Tour days9
Views2,320
Favorites208
How are the schools in Butler?
3 schools rated nearby
Location
Butler, NJ, 07405
Price history
6 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Apr 11, 2026Listed For Sale$599,900—GSMLS
Jun 28, 2019Sold$360,500—GSMLS
Mar 30, 2019Listed For Sale$360,000—Terrie O'Connor Realtors
Aug 6, 2013Sold$275,000—GSMLS
Apr 30, 2013Listing Removed$269,000—Realty Executives Exceptional Realtors
Mar 27, 2013Listed For Sale$269,000—Realty Executives Exceptional Realtors
Listed For Sale$599,900
Apr 11, 2026•GSMLS
Sold$360,500
Jun 28, 2019•GSMLS
Listed For Sale$360,000
Mar 30, 2019•Terrie O'Connor Realtors
Sold$275,000
Aug 6, 2013•GSMLS
Listing Removed$269,000
Apr 30, 2013•Realty Executives Exceptional Realtors
Listed For Sale$269,000
Mar 27, 2013•Realty Executives Exceptional Realtors
Tax history
25 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 15, 2025$11,843$474,300
Apr 15, 2024$10,652$426,600
Apr 15, 2023$10,239$385,800
Apr 15, 2022$9,427$340,700
Apr 15, 2021$9,412$245,500
Apr 15, 2020$8,536$233,600
Apr 15, 2019$8,426$233,600
Apr 15, 2018$8,211$233,600
Apr 15, 2017$7,998$233,600
Apr 15, 2016$7,870$233,600
Apr 15, 2015$7,627$233,600
Apr 15, 2014$7,454$233,600
Apr 15, 2013$7,249$233,600
Apr 15, 2012$7,073$233,600
Apr 15, 2011$6,730$233,600
Apr 15, 2010$6,429$233,600
Apr 15, 2009$6,300$233,600
Apr 15, 2008—$233,600
Apr 15, 2007—$233,600
Apr 15, 2006—$233,600
Apr 15, 2005—$233,600
Apr 15, 2004—$233,600
Apr 15, 2003—$233,600
Apr 15, 2002—$92,900
Apr 15, 2001—$92,900
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Butler, NJ • Morris County
Nearby cities
Basking RidgeChathamDenvilleDoverHackettstownMorris PlainsMorristownParsippany
Nearby zip codes
07405
Similar homes
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX Listing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. All rights reserved. Notice: The dissemination of listings on this website does not constitute the consent required by N.J.A.C. 11:5.6.1 (n) for the advertisement of listings exclusively for sale by another broker. Any such consent must be obtained in writing from the listing broker.
No obligation · Same-day response