For Sale43d on marketHistoric · 164 yrs
5 Wendover Road
Setauket, NY, 11733 • East Setauket • Suffolk County
$1,599,000
$392/sqft
Down payment assistance available
5Beds
4Baths
4,079Sqft
1.6 acLot
1862Built
Property DNA
Waterfront Property
Beach Access
Colonial Style
Built 1862 · 164 years of history
Enhanced Security
Security System · Smoke Detector(s)
Outdoor Living
Deck
1 Fireplace
Wood Burning
Garage(s)
Garage(s)
Private Pool
Electric Heat · Fenced · In Ground · Pool Cover · Vinyl
2.5-Car Garage
Detached · Driveway · Garage
This home is getting attention
Listed 43 days ago · 2,570 views · 106 saves
Market activity
Demand and pricing signals for this listing
2,570 views
People checking out this listing
106 saves
Buyers have saved this home
43 days on market
Established listing
$392/sqft
Price per square foot
Selling Soon Prediction
ModerateThis home ranks in the top 43% of listings most likely to go under contract soon, based on market activity and demand signals.
Likelihood score
Want the full market analysis?
Get the detailed selling prediction score, comparable sales data, and price trend forecast for this property.
Free · Delivered to your inbox in minutes
About this home
Single Family · Built 1862 · Historic
Welcome to the Gray-Storck House, a remarkable historic residence in the heart of Setauket. Originally built in 1862, this stately home sits on nearly two private acres and offers the perfect balance of preserved character and thoughtful, modern renovation, beautifully designed for today's lifestyle. A long, natural drive leads to the landscaped property, complete with a three car, two story plumbed garage and a fenced, heated in-ground pool with a brand new liner. Inside the approximately 4,000 square foot home, you will quickly see why it was selected twice for the Three Village Historical Society's Candlelight House Tour. The main level features an expansive open-concept living and dining space with original hardwood floors, soaring ceilings, and exposed wood beams. Natural light fills the home, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The renovated kitchen is centered around an oversized island and appointed with brand new stainless steel KitchenAid appliances and granite countertops. Just beyond the sunroom, the newly added primary suite offers a serene retreat with tall ceilings, abundant natural light, an expansive closet, and a luxurious white marble ensuite bath. A ductless air conditioning unit ensures comfort year-round. An additional bedroom or office and a powder room complete the main floor. Upstairs, you will find three bedrooms and a full bath featuring a classic clawfoot tub and separate large shower. The fully finished basement, with two forms of egress and a full bath, provides flexible space for guests, recreation, work or extended living. Additional recent updates include a new roof and septic system. Just moments away, enjoy beach access and stunning sunsets over Setauket Harbor. Located within the Three Village School District, this exceptional property is conveniently situated between Port Jefferson Village and Ferry to the east and Stony Brook Village and Harbor to the west, with dining, shopping, and scenic attractions throughout. With only a handful of owners in its storied history, the Gray-Storck House is more than a home, it's a legacy, ready to welcome its next chapter.
Estimated monthly payment
Based on current rates
$10,534/month
Principal & Interest$8,402
Property Tax$1,599
Insurance$533
Down payment20% ($319,800)
3%50%
Est. 6.87% rate · 30yr fixed · $1,279,200 loan
Full calculator →Virtual Tour
Open in new tab ↗Loading virtual tour…
At a glance
Key facts and listing details
TypeSingle Family Residence, Residential
Year Built1862
HeatingBaseboard, Hot Water, Oil
CoolingDuctless, Wall/Window Unit(s)
Parking2 Garage spaces
Lot1.56 Acres
Days on Zillow43 Days
Price/sqft$392
Property
Home typeSingle Family
Sub-typeSingle Family Residence, Residential
StyleColonial
Year built1862
Systems
HeatingBaseboard, Hot Water, Oil
CoolingDuctless, Wall/Window Unit(s)
ConstructionAdvanced Framing Technique
Water / SewerPublic / Septic Tank
Parking & Outdoor
ParkingDetached, Driveway, Garage
Garage2.5 spaces
BasementFinished,Full,Storage Space,Walk-Out Access
Fireplaces1
Lot1.56 Acres
Location & Tax
NeighborhoodEast Setauket
Annual tax$24,856
Parcel0200089000600010000
Bathrooms & Fees
Full baths3
Features & details
17 categories of property features
Interior Features
Interior
First Floor Bedroom
First Floor Full Bath
Beamed Ceilings
Cathedral Ceiling(s)
Eat-in Kitchen
Formal Dining
Granite Counters
Kitchen Island
Marble Counters
Open Floorplan
Open Kitchen
Primary Bathroom
Master Downstairs
Storage
Appliances
Dishwasher
Dryer
Electric Cooktop
Electric Oven
Electric Range
Microwave
Oven
Refrigerator
Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
Washer
Oil Water Heater
Flooring
Hardwood
Tile
Heating
Baseboard
Hot Water
Oil
Cooling
Ductless
Wall/Window Unit(s)
Laundry
Washer/Dryer Hookup
In Basement
Fireplace
Wood Burning
Exterior Features
Exterior
Courtyard
Garden
Parking
Detached
Driveway
Garage
Construction
Advanced Framing Technique
Patio & Porch
Deck
Lot Features
Back Yard
Front Yard
Garden
Landscaped
Private
Sprinklers In Front
Sprinklers In Rear
Views
Security
Security System
Smoke Detector(s)
Pool Features
Electric Heat
Fenced
In Ground
Pool Cover
Vinyl
Utilities
Cable Available
Electricity Connected
Trash Collection Public
Water Connected
Other Equipment
Pool Equip/Cover
Other Structures
Garage(s)
Room details
15 rooms detailed
Master Bedroom
FirstBedroom1
FirstBedroom2
SecondBedroom3
SecondBedroom4
SecondMaster Bathroom
FirstListing insights
Market data and value estimates
StatusFor Sale
Days on market43
Tax rate1.85%
Price/sqft$392
On marketMar 12, 2026
PostedMar 2, 2026
Last sold$640,000
MLS updatedApr 11, 2026
Tour days9
Views2,570
Favorites106
How are the schools in Setauket?
3 schools rated nearby
Location
Setauket, NY, 11733
Price history
5 events
DateEventPrice$/sqftSource
Mar 12, 2026Listed For Sale$1,599,000$392OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
Jan 13, 2015Listing Removed$799,000$196Realty Connect USA
Aug 27, 2014Listed For Sale$799,000$196Realty Connect USA
Jun 30, 2009Sold$640,000$157Agent Provided
Feb 1, 2003Sold$630,000$154Public Record
Listed For Sale$1,599,000
Mar 12, 2026•$392/sqft•OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
Listing Removed$799,000
Jan 13, 2015•$196/sqft•Realty Connect USA
Listed For Sale$799,000
Aug 27, 2014•$196/sqft•Realty Connect USA
Sold$640,000
Jun 30, 2009•$157/sqft•Agent Provided
Sold$630,000
Feb 1, 2003•$154/sqft•Public Record
Tax history
19 years of records
YearTax paidAssessed value
Apr 15, 2024—$5,240
Apr 15, 2023—$4,240
Apr 15, 2022—$4,240
Apr 15, 2021—$4,240
Apr 15, 2020—$4,240
Apr 15, 2019—$4,240
Apr 15, 2018—$4,240
Apr 15, 2017$14,313$4,240
Apr 15, 2016—$4,240
Apr 15, 2015—$4,240
Apr 15, 2014—$4,240
Apr 15, 2013—$4,240
Apr 15, 2012—$4,240
Apr 15, 2011—$4,240
Apr 15, 2007$10,501$4,150
Apr 15, 2005$8,342$4,150
Apr 15, 2004$7,761$4,150
Apr 15, 2003$7,282$4,150
Apr 15, 2002$6,763$4,150
Nearby homes
Neighborhood details
Local context around this listing
Setauket, NY • Suffolk County
Nearby neighborhoods
East SetauketOld FieldPoquottStrongs Neck
Nearby cities
Bay ShoreBrentwoodCentral IslipHuntingtonHuntington StationLindenhurstPatchogueRonkonkoma
Nearby zip codes
11733
Similar homes
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2026-02-06 15:18:24 PST. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. [Click here for more information](/mls-disclaimers/#778)
No obligation · Same-day response