Off Market4233d on market

5391 Cayman Dr

Carmel, IN, 46033 • 46033 • Hamilton County

$876,000

$174/sqft

4Beds

6Baths

5,037Sqft

0.43 acLot

1994Built

Market activity

Demand and pricing signals for this listing

1 views

People checking out this listing

4233 days on market

Established listing

$174/sqft

Price per square foot

About this home

Single Family · Built 1994

This 5037 square foot single family home has 4 bedrooms and 6.0 bathrooms. This home is located at 5391 Cayman Dr, Carmel, IN 46033.

Estimated monthly payment

Based on current rates

$5,713/month

Principal & Interest$4,545

Property Tax$876

Insurance$292

Down payment20% ($175,200)

3%50%

Est. 6.75% rate · 30yr fixed · $700,800 loan

Full calculator →

At a glance

Key facts and listing details

TypeSingleFamily

Year Built1994

HeatingOther

CoolingCentral

ParkingGarage - Attached

Lot0.43 Acres

Property

Home typeSingle Family

Year built1994

Systems

HeatingOther

CoolingCentral

RoofAsphalt

Parking & Outdoor

ParkingGarage - Attached

BasementFinished

Lot0.43 Acres

Location & Tax

Neighborhood46033

Annual tax$6,856

Parcel291021007001000018

Features & details

4 categories of property features

Interior Features

Heating

Other

Cooling

Central

Fireplace

masonry

Exterior Features

Parking

Garage - Attached

Room details

2 rooms detailed

Family Room

Recreation Room

Listing insights

Market data and value estimates

StatusOff Market

Days on market4233

Est. value$876,000

Est. rent$4,694/mo

Tax rate0.90%

Price/sqft$174

Last sold$485,000

Tour days6

How are the schools in Carmel?

3 schools rated nearby

Cherry Tree Elementary School

Primary • Public • PK-5

0.7 mi

Clay Middle School

Middle • Public • 6-8

1.7 mi

Carmel High School

High • Public • 9-12

2.4 mi

Location

Carmel, IN, 46033

Expand map

Price history

4 events

DateEventPrice$/sqftSource

Sep 5, 2014Sold$485,000$96MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Aug 11, 2010Sold$456,500$91MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Jul 10, 2010Listed For Sale$499,900$99RE/MAX Real Estate Groups

Sep 26, 2002Sold$449,900$89MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Sold$485,000

Sep 5, 2014•$96/sqft•MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Sold$456,500

Aug 11, 2010•$91/sqft•MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Listed For Sale$499,900

Jul 10, 2010•$99/sqft•RE/MAX Real Estate Groups

Sold$449,900

Sep 26, 2002•$89/sqft•MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID

Tax history

20 years of records

YearTax paidAssessed value

Apr 9, 2024$6,856$616,600

Apr 9, 2023$6,003$614,800

Apr 9, 2022$5,372$526,000

Apr 9, 2021$5,015$475,000

Apr 9, 2020$4,992$443,800

Apr 9, 2019$5,107$441,800

Apr 9, 2018$5,067$458,200

Apr 9, 2017$4,773$454,700

Apr 9, 2016$4,678$435,200

Apr 9, 2014$4,742$434,200

Apr 9, 2013$4,603$421,600

Apr 9, 2012$4,455$408,200

Apr 9, 2011$4,516$415,400

Apr 9, 2010$4,990$449,600

Apr 9, 2009$7,737$449,600

Apr 9, 2007$4,559$440,000

Apr 9, 2006$5,086$417,000

Apr 9, 2005—$363,300

Apr 9, 2002$4,160$216,400

Apr 9, 2001$4,207$72,130

Nearby homes

Off Market

$754,200

4 bd4 ba5,850 sqft

5405 Cayman Dr, Carmel, IN

Off Market

$805,900

5 bd3.5 ba5,369 sqft

5377 Cayman Dr, Carmel, IN

Off Market

$780,500

4 bd2.5 ba5,069 sqft

5390 Cayman Dr, Carmel, IN

Off Market

$831,500

5 bd4.5 ba5,163 sqft

5368 Reese Ct, Carmel, IN

Recently Sold

$810,000

5 bd4 ba4,406 sqft

5404 Cayman Dr, Carmel, IN

Recently Sold

$854,000

5 bd5 ba5,451 sqft

5419 Cayman Dr, Carmel, IN

Off Market

$892,900

4 bd4 ba5,459 sqft

5374 Cayman Dr, Carmel, IN

Off Market

$847,000

5 bd4 ba4,959 sqft

5369 Cayman Dr, Carmel, IN

Neighborhood details

Local context around this listing

Carmel, IN • Hamilton County

Nearby neighborhoods

Home Place

Nearby cities

ArcadiaAtlantaCarmelCiceroFishersNoblesvilleSheridanWestfield

Nearby zip codes

460324603346074460824628046290

Similar homes

For Sale

$799,900

4 bd5 ba4,364 sqft

5474 Cayman Ct, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$875,000

4 bd5 ba4,082 sqft

14980 Oak Hollow Ln E, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$685,000

5 bd4 ba4,014 sqft

12448 Pasture View Ct, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$949,900

5 bd5 ba5,993 sqft

6549 Braemar Ave S, Noblesville, IN

For Sale

$825,000

3 bd3 ba2,841 sqft

2895 Twain Dr, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$699,990

4 bd4 ba4,117 sqft

14070 Brazos Dr, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$729,900

5 bd4 ba4,030 sqft

12479 Autumn Gate Way, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$835,000

3 bd3 ba2,788 sqft

13994 Matt St, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$849,000

4 bd3 ba3,826 sqft

15 Wildwood Dr, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$539,900

3 bd2 ba2,798 sqft

12656 Cerromar Ct, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$775,000

3 bd2 ba3,096 sqft

11733 Whisper Bay Ct, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$875,000

4 bd5 ba5,915 sqft

118 White Horse Ln, Fishers, IN

For Sale

$650,000

4 bd3 ba4,316 sqft

14933 W Blackwolf Run Dr, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$729,900

4 bd4 ba4,124 sqft

5983 Clearview Dr, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$639,900

4 bd3 ba3,585 sqft

12112 Roxbury Pl, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$509,900

4 bd4 ba3,036 sqft

5250 Ivy Hill Dr, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$838,500

5 bd5 ba4,492 sqft

16802 Oak Manor Dr, Westfield, IN

For Sale

$470,000

4 bd4 ba2,981 sqft

305 N Concord Ln, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$630,000

3 bd3 ba2,820 sqft

12720 Kiawah Dr, Carmel, IN

For Sale

$750,000

4 bd2 ba3,458 sqft

310 2nd St NE, Carmel, IN

Tour This Home

Pick a date

Preferred time

Apr 9, 2026

No obligation · Same-day confirmation · Takes 30 seconds

Need a different time? Request custom scheduling

Have a Question?

Get details on this property, the neighborhood, or the buying process.

Ask About This Property

We typically respond within a few hours

Download property brochure

Photos, details & neighborhood info in one PDF

Get brochure

Free · No sign-up required

Get pre-approved

Know your budget & strengthen your offer

Check eligibility

Value estimates

Live

Est. value$876,000

Est. rent$4,694/mo

Affordability$5,209/mo

Own a home nearby?

See what it's worth in today's market

Get estimate

Schedule Tour Ask

No obligation · Same-day response