For SaleHistoric · 89 yrs

5122 North Diversey BOULEVARD

Whitefish Bay, WI, 53217 • 53217 • Milwaukee County

$585,000

$360/sqft

Down payment assistance available

4Beds

2Baths

1,625Sqft

0.13 acLot

1937Built

Property DNA

4 highlights

Cape Cod Style

Built 1937 · 89 years of history

2-Car Garage

Garage Door Opener · Detached · 2 Car · 1 Space

Premium Finishes

Walk-In Closet(s)

Just Listed

Listed Apr 14, 2026

This home is getting attention

452 views · 30 saves

Market activity

Demand and pricing signals for this listing

452 views

People checking out this listing

30 saves

Buyers have saved this home

$360/sqft

Price per square foot

About this home

Single Family · Built 1937 · Historic

Updated Cape Cod in Fantastic Whitefish Bay location with hardwood floors throughout and upgrades everywhere, such as a Nest Thermostat and Jolie Shower Head with Filter. Two bedrooms (one currently used as a dining room) and a full updated bath on the main floor, two more bedrooms and a bath upstairs. Brand new, renovated kitchen features white shaker cabinets, quartz counters and beautiful backsplash. Finished rec room in the lower level adds great bonus space. 2024 roof on house and garage, newer A/C, brand new water heater, newer driveway. Large fenced yard with landscape lighting and a two-car garage. Walk to WFB shops, and dining and WORLD CLASS WFB schools. Agent owned Interest

Standout features identified

Our analysis highlights two-car garage, newer driveway, and nest thermostat as key attractions of this home.

Estimated monthly payment

Based on current rates

$3,815/month

Principal & Interest$3,035

Property Tax$585

Insurance$195

Down payment20% ($117,000)

3%50%

Est. 6.75% rate · 30yr fixed · $468,000 loan

Full calculator →

At a glance

Key facts and listing details

TypeSingle Family Residence

Year Built1937

HeatingElectric, Zoned

CoolingCentral Air

Parking2 Garage spaces

Lot5,662 sqft

Days on Zillow0

Price/sqft$360

Property

Home typeSingle Family

Sub-typeSingle Family Residence

StyleCape Cod

Condition21+ Years

Year built1937

Stories2

Systems

HeatingElectric, Zoned

CoolingCentral Air

ConstructionAluminum Trim, Vinyl Siding

Water / SewerPublic / Public Sewer

Parking & Outdoor

ParkingGarage Door Opener, Detached, 2 Car, 1 Space

Garage2 spaces

BasementFull,Partially Finished

FencingFenced Yard

Lot5,662 sqft

Location & Tax

Neighborhood53217

ZoningRES

Annual tax$5,095

Parcel2020276000

Bathrooms & Fees

Full baths1

Features & details

7 categories of property features

Interior Features

Interior

Pantry

Cathedral/vaulted ceiling

Walk-In Closet(s)

Appliances

Dishwasher

Disposal

Dryer

Microwave

Range

Refrigerator

Washer

Heating

Electric

Zoned

Cooling

Central Air

Exterior Features

Parking

Garage Door Opener

Detached

2 Car

1 Space

Construction

Aluminum Trim

Vinyl Siding

Lot Features

Sidewalks

Room details

7 rooms detailed

Master Bedroom

Main

13×10 ft130 sqft

Bedroom2

Main

10×10 ft100 sqft

Bedroom3

Upper

14×10 ft140 sqft

Bedroom4

Upper

13×10 ft130 sqft

Bathroom

Master Bedroom Bath: Tub/Shower Combo

Kitchen

Main

10×8 ft80 sqft

Listing insights

Market data and value estimates

StatusFor Sale

Est. value$583,400

Est. rent$2,888/mo

Tax rate1.71%

Price/sqft$360

On marketApr 14, 2026

PostedApr 14, 2026

Last sold$515,000

MLS statusActive

MLS updatedApr 14, 2026

Tour days9

Favorites30

How are the schools in Whitefish Bay?

3 schools rated nearby

Cumberland Elementary School

Primary • Public • PK-5

0.6 mi

Whitefish Bay Middle School

Middle • Public • 6-8

0.4 mi

Whitefish Bay High School

High • Public • 9-12

0.9 mi

Location

Whitefish Bay, WI, 53217

Expand map

Price history

17 events

DateEventPrice$/sqftSource

Apr 14, 2026Listed For Sale$585,000$360WIREX MLS

Mar 5, 2026Listing Removed$2,899$2Zillow Rentals

Feb 4, 2026Price Change$2,899$2Zillow Rentals

Jan 9, 2026Price Change$2,929$2Zillow Rentals

Dec 17, 2025Price Change$3,062$2Zillow Rentals

Dec 5, 2025Listed For Rent$3,195$2Zillow Rentals

Jul 26, 2024Listing Removed——Zillow Rentals

Jul 18, 2024Listed For Rent$3,250$2Zillow Rentals

Jun 26, 2024Sold$515,000$317WIREX MLS

Jun 14, 2024Pending Sale$450,000$277WIREX MLS

Jun 8, 2024Contingent$450,000$277WIREX MLS

Jun 6, 2024Listed For Sale$450,000$277WIREX MLS

May 16, 2022Sold$425,000$262WIREX MLS

May 2, 2022Pending Sale$369,900$228WIREX MLS

May 1, 2022Contingent$369,900$228WIREX MLS

Apr 28, 2022Listed For Sale$369,900$228WIREX MLS

Mar 22, 2017Sold$257,700$159Public Record

Listed For Sale$585,000

Apr 14, 2026•$360/sqft•WIREX MLS

Listing Removed$2,899

Mar 5, 2026•$2/sqft•Zillow Rentals

Price Change$2,899

Feb 4, 2026•$2/sqft•Zillow Rentals

Price Change$2,929

Jan 9, 2026•$2/sqft•Zillow Rentals

Price Change$3,062

Dec 17, 2025•$2/sqft•Zillow Rentals

Listed For Rent$3,195

Dec 5, 2025•$2/sqft•Zillow Rentals

Listing Removed—

Jul 26, 2024•Zillow Rentals

Listed For Rent$3,250

Jul 18, 2024•$2/sqft•Zillow Rentals

Sold$515,000

Jun 26, 2024•$317/sqft•WIREX MLS

Pending Sale$450,000

Jun 14, 2024•$277/sqft•WIREX MLS

Contingent$450,000

Jun 8, 2024•$277/sqft•WIREX MLS

Listed For Sale$450,000

Jun 6, 2024•$277/sqft•WIREX MLS

Sold$425,000

May 16, 2022•$262/sqft•WIREX MLS

Pending Sale$369,900

May 2, 2022•$228/sqft•WIREX MLS

Contingent$369,900

May 1, 2022•$228/sqft•WIREX MLS

Listed For Sale$369,900

Apr 28, 2022•$228/sqft•WIREX MLS

Sold$257,700

Mar 22, 2017•$159/sqft•Public Record

Tax history

22 years of records

YearTax paidAssessed value

Apr 14, 2022$4,957$272,600

Apr 14, 2021$5,901$272,600

Apr 14, 2020$5,901$272,600

Apr 14, 2019$6,028$272,600

Apr 14, 2018$5,609$222,300

Apr 14, 2017$5,066$222,300

Apr 14, 2016$5,032$222,300

Apr 14, 2015$5,008$222,300

Apr 14, 2014$4,933$222,300

Apr 14, 2012$5,218$240,000

Apr 14, 2010$5,190$240,000

Apr 14, 2009$4,962$240,000

Apr 14, 2008$4,746$240,000

Apr 14, 2007$4,829$240,000

Apr 14, 2006$4,875$176,000

Apr 14, 2005$4,787$176,000

Apr 14, 2004$4,799$176,000

Apr 14, 2003$4,514$173,000

Apr 14, 2002$4,425$173,000

Apr 14, 2001$4,279$173,000

Apr 14, 2000$4,079$131,500

Apr 14, 1999$3,761$126,500

Nearby homes

Off Market

$473,200

3 bd1.5 ba1,345 sqft

5114 N Diversey Blvd, Whitefish Bay, WI

Off Market

$468,900

3 bd1 ba

5128 N Diversey Blvd, Whitefish Bay, WI

Recently Sold

$291,500

3 bd2 ba1,216 sqft

5106 N Diversey Blvd, Whitefish Bay, WI

Off Market

$571,900

4 bd2 ba1,618 sqft

5134 N Diversey Blvd, Whitefish Bay, WI

Off Market

$411,100

3 bd1 ba944 sqft

5100 N Diversey Blvd, Whitefish Bay, WI

Off Market

$850,900

4 bd3 ba2,097 sqft

5129 N Hollywood Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI

Off Market

$601,100

3 bd2 ba1,438 sqft

518 E Lancaster Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI

Off Market

$697,200

3 bd2 ba1,658 sqft

5123 N Hollywood Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI

Neighborhood details

Local context around this listing

Whitefish Bay, WI • Milwaukee County

Nearby cities

CudahyFranklinGreendaleGreenfieldMilwaukeeOak CreekSouth MilwaukeeWauwatosa

Nearby zip codes

5321153217

Similar homes

For Sale

$384,900

4 bd2 ba2,200 sqft

5440 North Navajo AVENUE, Glendale, WI

For Sale

$579,900

3 bd3 ba2,200 sqft

7125 N Longacre Rd, Milwaukee, WI

For Sale

$589,000

3 bd2 ba2,404 sqft

2400 East Newton AVENUE, Shorewood, WI

For Sale

$379,900

4 bd3 ba1,768 sqft

333 West Bender ROAD, Glendale, WI

For Sale

$524,989

5 bd3 ba2,142 sqft

1532 North 124th STREET, Wauwatosa, WI

2742 South Greeley STREET, Milwaukee, WI

For Sale

$495,000

4 bd3 ba1,550 sqft

2742 South Greeley STREET, Milwaukee, WI

For Sale

$599,900

3 bd2 ba1,911 sqft

13002 North Phillip DRIVE, Mequon, WI

For Sale

$449,900

3 bd2 ba1,404 sqft

3227 North 104th STREET, Wauwatosa, WI

For Sale

$429,000

3 bd2 ba1,963 sqft

860 West La Salle AVENUE, Glendale, WI

1850 North Arlington PLACE, Milwaukee, WI

For Sale

$625,000

2 bd3 ba2,200 sqft

1850 North Arlington PLACE, Milwaukee, WI

For Sale

$599,000

3 bd2 ba2,077 sqft

1970 North 166th STREET, Brookfield, WI

6531 North LANDERS STREET, Milwaukee, WI

For Sale

$297,900

3 bd3 ba1,063 sqft

6531 North LANDERS STREET, Milwaukee, WI

For Sale

$305,000

4 bd2 ba1,950 sqft

1022 South 90th STREET, West Allis, WI

W204N6938 Lannon ROAD, Menomonee Falls, WI

For Sale

$399,900

3 bd2 ba1,633 sqft

W204N6938 Lannon ROAD, Menomonee Falls, WI

For Sale

$499,900

3 bd3 ba2,072 sqft

2285 North 166th STREET, Brookfield, WI

For Sale

$429,900

4 bd2 ba1,511 sqft

1100 Alfred STREET, Brookfield, WI

5155 West County Line ROAD, Brown Deer, WI

For Sale

$499,000

3 bd2 ba1,738 sqft

5155 West County Line ROAD, Brown Deer, WI

For Sale

$475,000

3 bd3 ba2,120 sqft

11004 North Range Line ROAD, Mequon, WI

For Sale

$309,900

3 bd3 ba1,125 sqft

4422 Glenway STREET, Wauwatosa, WI

W184N8293 Tours DRIVE, Menomonee Falls, WI

For Sale

$549,000

4 bd3 ba2,367 sqft

W184N8293 Tours DRIVE, Menomonee Falls, WI

Tour This Home

Available dates

Select a time

Apr 14, 2026

High demand — 452 people viewed this listing. Tours fill up fast.

No obligation · Same-day confirmation · Takes 30 seconds

Need a different time? Request custom scheduling

Have a Question?

Get details on this property, the neighborhood, or the buying process.

Ask About This Property

We typically respond within a few hours

Download property brochure

Photos, details & neighborhood info in one PDF

Get brochure

Free · No sign-up required

Get pre-approved

Know your budget & strengthen your offer

Check eligibility

Down Payment Assistance

Learn how to qualify

Value estimates

Live

Est. value$583,400

Est. rent$2,888/mo

Affordability$3,874/mo

Own a home nearby?

See what it's worth in today's market

Get estimate

Schedule Tour Ask

No obligation · Same-day response