Off MarketHistoric · 94 yrs

509 Baumgardner Rd

Willow Street, PA, 17584 • 17584 • Lancaster County

$392,600

$175/sqft

3Beds

1Baths

2,240Sqft

1.4 acLot

1932Built

Property DNA

1 highlights

Colonial Style

Built 1932 · 94 years of history

Market activity

Demand and pricing signals for this listing

3 views

People checking out this listing

$175/sqft

Price per square foot

About this home

Single Family · Built 1932 · Historic

This 2240 square foot single family home has 3 bedrooms and 1.0 bathrooms. This home is located at 509 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA 17584.

Estimated monthly payment

Based on current rates

$2,416/month

Principal & Interest$1,892

Property Tax$393

Insurance$131

Down payment20% ($78,520)

3%50%

Est. 6.04% rate · 30yr fixed · $314,080 loan

Full calculator →

At a glance

Key facts and listing details

TypeSingleFamily

Year Built1932

HeatingOther, Other

ParkingNo Data

Lot1.40 Acres

Property

Home typeSingle Family

StyleColonial

Year built1932

Systems

HeatingOther, Other

RoofComposition

ConstructionFrame

Parking & Outdoor

BasementPartially finished

Lot1.40 Acres

Location & Tax

Neighborhood17584

Annual tax$5,364

Parcel5109347100000

Features & details

3 categories of property features

Interior Features

Heating

Other

Exterior Features

Exterior

Other

Construction

Frame

Listing insights

Market data and value estimates

StatusOff Market

Est. value$392,600

Est. rent$1,716/mo

Tax rate1.24%

Price/sqft$175

Tour days6

How are the schools in Willow Street?

3 schools rated nearby

Pequea El School

Elementary • Public • K-6

0.7 mi

Marticville Middle School

Middle • Public • 7-8

2.8 mi

Penn Manor High School

High • Public • 9-12

4.6 mi

Location

Willow Street, PA, 17584

Expand map

Tax history

24 years of records

YearTax paidAssessed value

Apr 15, 2025$5,364$232,900

Apr 15, 2024$5,220$232,900

Apr 15, 2023$5,220$232,900

Apr 15, 2022$5,124$232,900

Apr 15, 2021$5,124$232,900

Apr 15, 2020$1,043$232,900

Apr 15, 2019$4,862$232,900

Apr 15, 2018$1,043$232,900

Apr 15, 2017$3,997$160,500

Apr 15, 2016$3,997$160,500

Apr 15, 2015$2,708$160,500

Apr 15, 2014$2,708$160,500

Apr 15, 2013—$160,500

Apr 15, 2012—$160,500

Apr 15, 2011—$160,500

Apr 15, 2010—$160,500

Apr 15, 2009—$160,500

Apr 15, 2007—$160,500

Apr 15, 2006—$160,500

Apr 15, 2005—$136,100

Apr 15, 2004—$113,700

Apr 15, 2003—$113,700

Apr 15, 2002—$113,700

Apr 15, 2000—$113,700

Nearby homes

Off Market

$358,500

3 bd1 ba1,782 sqft

521 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA

Off Market

$404,300

4 bd2 ba2,060 sqft

501 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA

For Sale

$50,000

4 bd2 ba1,476 sqft

527 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA

Off Market

$308,300

3 bd1 ba1,560 sqft

529 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA

Off Market

$363,900

3 bd1.5 ba1,923 sqft

485 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA

Off Market

$301,200

5 bd1.5 ba1,424 sqft

533 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA

Off Market

$45,500

Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA

Recently Sold

$80,000

Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street, PA

Neighborhood details

Local context around this listing

Willow Street, PA • Lancaster County

Nearby cities

ColumbiaDenverElizabethtownEphrataLancasterLititzManheimMount Joy

Nearby zip codes

175681758317584

Similar homes

For Sale

$364,900

4 bd2 ba1,404 sqft

148 Mallard Ave, Willow Street, PA

For Sale

$425,000

3 bd2 ba2,130 sqft

670 Marticville Rd, Pequea, PA

For Sale

$400,000

3 bd3 ba2,692 sqft

186 Shenks Ferry Rd, Conestoga, PA

For Sale

$400,000

4 bd2 ba2,700 sqft

8 Elk Cir, New Providence, PA

For Sale

$400,000

5 bd2 ba2,170 sqft

597 Lancaster Pike, New Providence, PA

For Sale

$359,900

3 bd2 ba2,155 sqft

157 Jimanna Rd, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$259,900

3 bd2 ba1,390 sqft

113 Westmore Way, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$299,900

3 bd1 ba1,440 sqft

611 Beaver Valley Pike, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$525,000

3 bd3 ba2,032 sqft

2460 Honeysuckle Ln, Lancaster, PA

Legacy III Plan, Southern Village, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$399,900

3 bd3 ba1,665 sqft

Legacy III Plan, Southern Village, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$374,500

5 bd2 ba1,578 sqft

118 W Frederick St, Millersville, PA

For Sale

$475,000

4 bd2 ba1,550 sqft

135 Miller St, Strasburg, PA

For Sale

$549,900

3 bd3 ba1,985 sqft

1 W Kendig Rd, Willow Street, PA

Heritage III Plan, Southern Village, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$425,900

3 bd3 ba1,871 sqft

Heritage III Plan, Southern Village, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$320,000

3 bd2 ba1,879 sqft

92 Euclid Ave, Lancaster, PA

Baxter Plan, Southern Village, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$465,900

4 bd3 ba1,800 sqft

Baxter Plan, Southern Village, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$350,000

5 bd1 ba1,478 sqft

644 E Madison St, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$335,000

4 bd3 ba1,944 sqft

549 Rockland St, Lancaster, PA

Spring Ridge Plan, Southern Village, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$475,900

3 bd2 ba1,640 sqft

Spring Ridge Plan, Southern Village, Lancaster, PA

For Sale

$399,900

3 bd3 ba1,665 sqft

116 Hillard Fld, Lancaster, PA

Tour This Home

Pick a date

Preferred time

Apr 15, 2026

No obligation · Same-day confirmation · Takes 30 seconds

Need a different time? Request custom scheduling

Have a Question?

Get details on this property, the neighborhood, or the buying process.

Ask About This Property

We typically respond within a few hours

Download property brochure

Photos, details & neighborhood info in one PDF

Get brochure

Free · No sign-up required

Get pre-approved

Know your budget & strengthen your offer

Check eligibility

Value estimates

Live

Est. value$392,600

Est. rent$1,716/mo

30yr rate est.6.04%

Affordability$2,418/mo

Own a home nearby?

See what it's worth in today's market

Get estimate

Schedule Tour Ask

No obligation · Same-day response